steady

Family · Parents and in-laws

Ask about their life, and write it down

15 minEvidence: worth trying

Do this

Next time you're with your mother or father, ask one question about their life you can't answer yourself. Write down what they said that evening.

How to do it

  1. Ask one question you can't answer yourself. "What was your first job?" "Where did you live at my age?"
  2. Let them tell it. The studies were about going over a life with someone who listens.
  3. Write it down that evening and keep it where you'll find it. Recalling it soon keeps more of it.
  4. Don't count the calls. More calls didn't reliably mean a closer tie with a parent.

What the telling gives

  1. Life reviewhelps older people

    In structured sessions, going back over one's life with someone who listens eased depression and strengthened the sense that life made sense.

  2. Legacy talkhelps, doesn't cure

    Seriously ill patients recorded their story and got it back as a document for family. It didn't lower distress; they said it helped their family.

  3. Recallkeeps it

    Students who recalled a passage kept more of it a week later than those who reread it. Writing it down that evening is a kind of recall; applying it here is a guess.

  4. Youhave it written

    The home version is untested. The plain reason to do it anyway is that some questions have a deadline.

Why it works

"What was your first job?" "Where did you live when you were my age?" Small questions, answered once, written down.

Going back over your life with someone who listens has been studied a lot in older people, with moderate benefits. Evidence: decent Neither that nor the version for the seriously ill was tested as something a son does at the kitchen table. Evidence: decent The home version is untested. Evidence: worth trying The plain reason to do it anyway: some questions have a deadline.

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.

What happens in your brain

Going back over a life. A review of 128 studies found moderate improvements in depression, and in what researchers call ego integrity: the sense that your life has made sense. Evidence: decent Most of the gains were still there at follow-up. Evidence: decent

A legacy talk helps, but doesn't cure. Dignity Therapy is a structured version, a guided conversation about a person's life and what they want to leave behind. The session is recorded, typed up, edited, read back to the patient, and given to them to pass on to someone they choose. Evidence: decent It was tested with seriously ill patients in palliative care, the care given when an illness can no longer be cured. In a trial that finished with 326 of them, it didn't lower overall distress, the main thing measured. Evidence: decent Patients did report less sadness than with standard care, and better spiritual wellbeing than with one of the other approaches. Evidence: worth trying They were also more likely to say it had helped their family and changed how their family saw them. Evidence: decent

Writing it down keeps it. Recalling something soon after, rather than going over it again, makes it last. Evidence: solid Students who recalled a passage they'd read remembered far more of it a week later than students who reread it. Evidence: solid Writing down a parent's answer that evening is a kind of recall; that it works the same way for a story you heard is a guess. Evidence: worth trying

You have it written. What the home version does for your parent, or for you, hasn't been studied. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • A review of 128 controlled studies of reminiscence found moderate improvements in ego integrity and depression, and smaller ones in purpose in life and wellbeing. Most held at follow-up. The biggest drops in depression were in people who were already depressed or chronically ill. Evidence: decent
  • 441 patients with six months or less to live were randomly given Dignity Therapy, client-centred care or standard palliative care; 326 were analysed. Distress didn't differ between the groups. Afterwards, Dignity Therapy patients were more likely to say it had helped them and their family. Evidence: decent
  • 180 students read a prose passage. A week later, those who had recalled it three times remembered 61%; those who had reread it remembered 40%. Five minutes after, rereading had been ahead. Evidence: solid
  • 601 adults aged 40 to 60, from the Philadelphia area, rated their relationships with 813 living parents. More phone or email contact went with a worse relationship for fathers limited in daily activities by their health, and a warmer one for fathers without those limits. Measured once, so it can't say which way it runs. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • Ask one question about their life you can't answer yourself.
  • Listen to the whole answer. Evidence: worth trying
  • Write down what they said that evening. Evidence: worth trying
  • Keep the notes together. Next visit, one more question.
  • Don't count the calls. More contact was not reliably a better relationship in that study. Evidence: decent One real question is a better use of the call than keeping score. Evidence: worth trying Go easy on advice about their health. Evidence: worth trying

Watch out

Neither study was of a son asking at the kitchen table. Those were older people in structured sessions and seriously ill patients in clinical care. Evidence: decent The recall study used students and texts, not family stories. Evidence: solid The calls study was one group, measured once. With fathers in good health, more calls went with a warmer relationship, so it's no reason to call less. Evidence: decent

If your parent is seriously ill, ask their hospice or palliative care team. They can point you to Dignity Therapy or something like it, done properly.

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.