steady

Family · Brothers and sisters

Ask your brother one specific question

2 minEvidence: worth trying

Do this

Send your brother or sister one question they can answer in a line. Not "how are you". Something only they would know.

How to do it

  1. One question, answerable in a line. It asks for an answer, not a report on your life.
  2. Something only they would know. "Do you still have Dad's old tools?" That a shared memory works better than "how are you" is a guess.
  3. Send it even if it feels odd. The other side liked being contacted more than senders predicted.
  4. If it goes nowhere, send another next month. One message is two minutes.

How one question lands

  1. Questionasks for a real answer

    In live conversations, people who asked more questions, follow-ups most of all, came across as listening and were liked more. Those were strangers, not brothers.

  2. Surpriselands better than you fear

    People reaching out after a long gap underestimated how much it was appreciated. The gap was biggest between people who weren't close.

  3. Siblingsmatter later

    In men followed for thirty years, poor ties to brothers and sisters before 20 went with more depression by 50.

  4. Youhave somewhere to start

    Whether getting back in touch at forty changes anything hasn't been tested. That step is a guess.

Why it works

"How are you" gets "fine". A specific question gets an answer, and an answer is somewhere to start. Evidence: worth trying "Do you still have Dad's old tools?" "What was the name of that teacher who hated us both?"

The message itself tends to be more welcome than you'd guess. People who reached out after a gap underestimated how much the other person appreciated it. Evidence: decent

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.

What happens in your brain

A question asks for a real answer. In three studies of live conversations, people who asked more questions, especially follow-up questions, were liked more by the person they talked to. Asking came across as listening, understanding and caring. Evidence: decent Those were strangers getting to know each other and speed daters, not brothers. That a specific question beats a general one hasn't been tested. Evidence: worth trying

The surprise lands well. Across 13 preregistered studies, people who sent a short message or a small gift to someone in their circle underestimated how much it was appreciated. Evidence: decent The authors' explanation is surprise: the person contacted focuses on the pleasant surprise of being thought of, and the sender doesn't. The underestimate was bigger between people who weren't close. Evidence: decent

Brothers and sisters matter later. A long study followed a group of Harvard men from about twenty into their fifties. The ones who had been close to their brothers and sisters when young were less likely to have had major depression by midlife. Evidence: decent Poor ties to brothers and sisters before 20 went with more depression by 50 even after allowing for how they'd got on with their parents. A family history of depression predicted it separately. Evidence: decent

You have somewhere to start. Whether a question now changes anything that was set then is untested. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • Across 13 preregistered studies, nine in the main paper and four supplementary, people who reached out underestimated how much it was appreciated. That held for brief messages and small gifts, and for close and distant ties. Evidence: decent
  • In one of them, people recalled the last time they'd got in touch, or been got in touch with, "just to catch up" after a long time without contact. Senders rated the welcome lower than receivers did. Evidence: decent
  • 229 men, selected for good health, were followed from about 20 to 50 and beyond. Poorer relationships with brothers and sisters before 20 went with more major depression by 50. Evidence: decent
  • In three studies of live conversations, people who asked more questions, especially follow-ups, were liked more. Speed daters who asked more follow-ups got more yeses to a second date. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • One question they can answer in a line. Evidence: worth trying
  • Make it something only they would know. "Do you still have Dad's old tools?" "What was the name of that teacher who hated us both?"
  • Send it even if it feels odd. In the studies, the other side liked being contacted more than the sender expected. Evidence: decent
  • One question takes two minutes. If it goes nowhere, send another next month.

Watch out

The sibling study was all men, mostly white, all from one university. Evidence: decent And it's about the relationship you had then, not about repairing it now. Nobody has tested whether getting back in touch at forty changes anything. Evidence: worth trying The reach-out studies had people, some of them students, contact someone in their social circle, not brothers and sisters. Evidence: decent

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.