steady

Family · Parents and in-laws

Expect the mixed feeling

Evidence: worth trying

Do this

After a call or a visit with a parent that left you irritated, tell yourself one line: "Both. I love them and they annoy me." Then leave it there.

How to do it

  1. Say both halves. "I love them and they annoy me." Close family was the most mixed tie people had.
  2. Then leave it there. No verdict on the relationship needed.
  3. One plain line, not an analysis. Naming a feeling was enough in the lab.
  4. If one word works better, use one word. "Annoyed" is fine.

How the mix plays outTap a word for what it means

  1. Ambivalencelove and irritation at once

    People mapping their relationships rated close family as more mixed than friends or distant relatives. The closer they felt, the more mixed.

  2. Wellbeinglower with more mix

    In 158 families, parents and grown children who reported more of the mix reported feeling worse. Measured once, so the direction is unknown.

  3. Prefrontalputs a word on it

    Naming a feeling made a patch of the right prefrontal cortex more active and the amygdala less. That was people labelling pictures in a scanner; that it applies to a parent is a guess.

  4. Youskip the verdict

    Saying both halves keeps one bad call from turning into a theory about your family. Nobody has tested that.

Why it works

Warmth and irritation at the same time is ordinary between grown children and their parents. Evidence: decent The irritation doesn't mean the relationship is broken, and it doesn't need a verdict. Saying both halves keeps one bad call from turning into a theory about your whole family. Nobody has tested that. Evidence: worth trying

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 2 min read.

What happens in your brain

Love and irritation at once. Researchers call it ambivalence: two opposite feelings about the same person, together. A study of 158 families, with mothers, fathers and grown sons and daughters, found it in both generations. Evidence: decent In a separate study, people rated their partner, parents, children and brothers and sisters as more mixed than friends or more distant relatives, and the closer they felt to someone, the more mixed the feeling. Evidence: decent

More mix, lower wellbeing. The same family study found that people who reported more of the mix also reported feeling worse, parents and children alike. It was measured once, by asking people, so it can't say which comes first. Evidence: decent

Naming it helps a bit. Putting a feeling into a word is called affect labelling. In a brain-scan study, naming the emotion in negative images made the amygdala less active and a patch of the right prefrontal cortex more active; the busier that patch, the quieter the amygdala. Evidence: decent That was pictures in a scanner, not a parent; that it works after a call is a guess. Evidence: worth trying

You skip the verdict. One line with both halves in it is the whole move. Evidence: worth trying If one word works better for you, name it in one word.

The proof

  • 187 people aged 13 to 99 mapped 3,392 relationships. Close family ties, partner, children, parents and siblings, were rated more mixed than more distant relatives, friends or acquaintances, and feeling closer to someone went with more ambivalence. Evidence: decent
  • 158 families, 474 people: a mother, a father and a son or daughter aged 22 to 49. Parents and grown children who reported more ambivalence reported poorer psychological wellbeing. Evidence: decent
  • In a scan study, labelling the emotion in negative images, rather than handling them another way, went with less amygdala activity and more in the right ventrolateral prefrontal cortex. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • After the call, say both halves: "I love them and they annoy me." Evidence: worth trying
  • Then leave it there. No verdict.
  • If one word fits better, use one word.

Watch out

The family studies are snapshots and self-reports; they can't tell cause from effect. Evidence: decent The 158-family study was in the Philadelphia area and only took families living within 50 miles of each other. Evidence: decent The brain evidence comes from pictures in a scanner, not real calls. Evidence: decent If the irritation has turned into not wanting any contact with your family, and your mood has been low along with it, that's worth a doctor conversation. It's a normal one.

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.