How to do it
- Brief and calm. One sentence for why, no lecture, no raised voice.
- Same place every time, near you, not shut away.
- When it's over, be warm and move on. The evidence is for time-out inside a warm relationship.
- Never a smack instead. It doesn't work, and it goes with harm. Don't.
How the time-out works
- Attentionpauses briefly
Time-out is short for time out from positive reinforcement. A short break from your attention and the fun is the learning idea it's built on.
- Arousalcomes down
A few quiet minutes near you. That this helps a kid settle is the reviewers' reasoning, not something measured here; that step is a guess.
- Warmthcomes straight back
The evidence is for time-out inside a warm relationship. In 474 families, time-out done well went with better attachment.
- Themact up less
Parenting programmes that taught time-out had bigger effects on how kids behaved.
Why it works
You'll read that time-out damages the bond between you and your kid. A review of the research found no trial evidence for that. Used well, time-out is one of the better-supported tools parents have. Evidence: decent
"Used well" is the catch. Brief, calm, and warm the rest of the time. The evidence is for that version, inside a warm relationship, not for a long, angry one instead of it.
The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 2 min read.
What happens in your brain
Your attention pauses. Time-out is short for time out from positive reinforcement: a brief break from your attention and whatever was fun. That's the learning idea it's built on. Evidence: decent
Things come down. A few quiet minutes, near you, not shut away. The review's authors argue that, done this way, time-out fits what's known about attachment and self-control and supports the child's wellbeing. Evidence: decent That it calms the child's body hasn't been measured; that step is an inference. Evidence: worth trying
Warmth comes straight back. In a survey of 474 Australian parents of six- to eight-year-olds, time-out done the recommended way went with better child mental health and a more secure bond. Time-out done badly went with worse outcomes. Evidence: decent It's a snapshot, a correlation, not a trial.
They act up less. Across 77 evaluations of parenting programmes for children up to seven, the programmes that taught time-out had bigger effects. Evidence: solid
The proof
- 77 evaluations of parenting programmes for children up to seven: teaching time-out was one of the parts that went with bigger effects, after allowing for differences in study design. Evidence: solid
- 474 parents of six- to eight-year-olds, a nationally representative Australian sample: time-out done well went with better mental health and attachment, done badly with worse. The link to better attachment was strongest in children who'd been through hard times. Evidence: decent
- Families in a US early childhood programme were followed from age three to fifth grade. Children whose parents used time-out at three did no worse on any emotional or behavioural measure than those whose parents didn't. Evidence: decent
- Across 160,927 children, smacking was linked to 13 of 17 outcomes, every one in the harmful direction. It doesn't work. Don't. Evidence: solid
How to do it
- Short and calm. One sentence for why. No lecture, no raised voice.
- Same place every time, near you, not shut away.
- When it's over, be warm and move on.
Watch out
That programme analysis stopped at seven. For older kids it doesn't say. Evidence: solid
Time-out done badly went with worse outcomes in the survey. Evidence: decent Some of the researchers behind the recent time-out studies also developed a parenting programme that includes it. Evidence: decent