steady

Family · With the kids

The time-out that works

5 minEvidence: decent

Do this

Short, calm, same place every time, near you, not shut away. One sentence for why, no lecture, no raised voice. When it's over, be warm and move on.

How to do it

  1. Brief and calm. One sentence for why, no lecture, no raised voice.
  2. Same place every time, near you, not shut away.
  3. When it's over, be warm and move on. The evidence is for time-out inside a warm relationship.
  4. Never a smack instead. It doesn't work, and it goes with harm. Don't.

How the time-out works

  1. Attentionpauses briefly

    Time-out is short for time out from positive reinforcement. A short break from your attention and the fun is the learning idea it's built on.

  2. Arousalcomes down

    A few quiet minutes near you. That this helps a kid settle is the reviewers' reasoning, not something measured here; that step is a guess.

  3. Warmthcomes straight back

    The evidence is for time-out inside a warm relationship. In 474 families, time-out done well went with better attachment.

  4. Themact up less

    Parenting programmes that taught time-out had bigger effects on how kids behaved.

Why it works

You'll read that time-out damages the bond between you and your kid. A review of the research found no trial evidence for that. Used well, time-out is one of the better-supported tools parents have. Evidence: decent

"Used well" is the catch. Brief, calm, and warm the rest of the time. The evidence is for that version, inside a warm relationship, not for a long, angry one instead of it.

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 2 min read.

What happens in your brain

Your attention pauses. Time-out is short for time out from positive reinforcement: a brief break from your attention and whatever was fun. That's the learning idea it's built on. Evidence: decent

Things come down. A few quiet minutes, near you, not shut away. The review's authors argue that, done this way, time-out fits what's known about attachment and self-control and supports the child's wellbeing. Evidence: decent That it calms the child's body hasn't been measured; that step is an inference. Evidence: worth trying

Warmth comes straight back. In a survey of 474 Australian parents of six- to eight-year-olds, time-out done the recommended way went with better child mental health and a more secure bond. Time-out done badly went with worse outcomes. Evidence: decent It's a snapshot, a correlation, not a trial.

They act up less. Across 77 evaluations of parenting programmes for children up to seven, the programmes that taught time-out had bigger effects. Evidence: solid

The proof

  • 77 evaluations of parenting programmes for children up to seven: teaching time-out was one of the parts that went with bigger effects, after allowing for differences in study design. Evidence: solid
  • 474 parents of six- to eight-year-olds, a nationally representative Australian sample: time-out done well went with better mental health and attachment, done badly with worse. The link to better attachment was strongest in children who'd been through hard times. Evidence: decent
  • Families in a US early childhood programme were followed from age three to fifth grade. Children whose parents used time-out at three did no worse on any emotional or behavioural measure than those whose parents didn't. Evidence: decent
  • Across 160,927 children, smacking was linked to 13 of 17 outcomes, every one in the harmful direction. It doesn't work. Don't. Evidence: solid

How to do it

  • Short and calm. One sentence for why. No lecture, no raised voice.
  • Same place every time, near you, not shut away.
  • When it's over, be warm and move on.

Watch out

That programme analysis stopped at seven. For older kids it doesn't say. Evidence: solid

Time-out done badly went with worse outcomes in the survey. Evidence: decent Some of the researchers behind the recent time-out studies also developed a parenting programme that includes it. Evidence: decent

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.