steady

Family · With the kids

Pick the one rule you'll actually hold

5 minEvidence: decent

Do this

Pick one rule for this week. Agree the wording with your partner if you have one. Say it the same way and follow through the same way every time, tired or not.

How to do it

  1. Pick one rule for this week. One you hold every time is worth more than five you hold when you have the energy.
  2. Agree the exact words with your partner. If you handle it differently, the kid has two rules.
  3. Agree what happens when it's broken. Same response, every time.
  4. Tired or not. Doing the same thing every time was one of the parts with bigger effects.

How the rule sticks

  1. Same rulesame result, every time

    One rule, said the same way, followed by the same thing. That's the whole move.

  2. Learningthey learn what follows

    Children learn from what reliably follows what they do. That this is why consistency works here is an inference; the review only shows that it does.

  3. Two parentsone rule, not two

    Across 93 studies, parents who pulled together rather than against each other went with slightly fewer behaviour problems. A small correlation.

  4. Youhold it tired

    The review found consistency mattered. That one rule held every time beats five held sometimes is my reading of it, not something it tested.

Why it works

A large review of parenting programmes for children up to seven pulled apart which parts did the work. Responding to the same behaviour the same way every time was one of the parts with bigger effects. Evidence: solid

One rule you hold every time is worth more than five you hold when you have the energy. That's my reading of it, not something the review tested. Evidence: worth trying

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 2 min read.

What happens in your brain

Same rule, same result. The rule is said the same way and followed by the same thing, every time. That's what the programmes with bigger effects taught parents to do. Evidence: solid

They learn what follows. Children learn from what reliably follows what they do. That this is the reason consistency works is an inference; the review shows that it goes with bigger effects, not why. Evidence: worth trying

Two parents, one rule. If you and your partner handle it differently, the kid has two rules. Across 93 studies with 41,207 people, parents who pulled together, rather than competing or fighting over the child, went with slightly fewer behaviour problems in their kids. Evidence: decent It's a small correlation, and it measured how parents worked together overall, not whether they agreed on rules. Evidence: decent

You hold it when you're tired. That's the hard part, and the one the review points at. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • 77 published evaluations of parenting programmes for children up to seven: after allowing for differences in study design, programmes that taught the importance of consistency had bigger effects. Evidence: solid
  • The other parts with bigger effects in the same review: more warm time together and talking about feelings, teaching time-out, and practising the new skills with your own child during the sessions. Evidence: solid
  • 93 studies, 41,207 people: co-parenting that worked together went with slightly fewer behaviour problems and less anxiety and low mood in children. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • Pick one rule for this week.
  • Agree the words with your partner, and agree what happens when it's broken.
  • Say it the same way, follow through the same way, every time, tired or not.

Watch out

The review stopped at seven. Older kids still need rules. The evidence here just doesn't cover them. Evidence: solid

What happens when it's broken should be calm and brief. See the time-out that works.

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.