steady

Family · With the kids

Five minutes where they lead

5 minEvidence: decent

Do this

Once a day, five minutes with your kid doing whatever they pick. You follow, describe what they're doing, no questions, no phone, no teaching.

How to do it

  1. Five minutes, once a day. That's the programme's daily homework.
  2. They pick, you follow. Copy what they do and join in.
  3. Say out loud what they're doing. No questions, no instructions, no teaching. That's the hard part.
  4. Phone away. With teenagers the version is their music in the car, no comment.

How the play half works

  1. Attentiongoes where they lead

    Following and describing is attention they get without acting up. The programme's first half is built on that idea.

  2. No questionsthey stay in charge

    Questions and instructions take the lead back. The programme coaches parents to drop them in play; that part was never tested on its own.

  3. The bondwarms up

    In 100 families going through the play half, mothers reported less disruptive behaviour and less stress. There was no comparison group.

  4. Youless on edge

    In the trials, the whole programme lowered parents' stress. Whether five minutes alone does is not known.

Why it works

This is lifted from a parenting programme with a strong track record, Parent-Child Interaction Therapy: five minutes a day where the child is in charge and the parent just narrates and joins in. Across 23 trials the full programme, coached sessions plus this daily homework, cuts behaviour problems by a large margin and lowers parents' stress. Evidence: solid The five minutes on their own have never been tested apart from the rest. Evidence: worth trying

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 2 min read.

What happens in your brain

Your attention goes where they lead. The programme's first half, the play half, teaches parents to give attention to what the child is doing well and to follow their lead. Evidence: decent Kids get attention without having to act up for it. That's the idea behind it, not a measured result. Evidence: worth trying

They stay in charge. Questions, instructions and teaching all take the lead back. The programme coaches parents to cut them during play and to describe, copy and praise instead. Evidence: decent That rule is part of the method; it hasn't been tested on its own. Evidence: worth trying

Things warm up. In 100 mothers of three- to six-year-olds with serious defiance, mothers reported less disruptive behaviour, less parenting stress and better parenting after the play half. Evidence: worth trying There was no comparison group, and the play half includes weekly coaching, not only the homework.

You're less on edge. Across the trials, the whole programme lowered parents' stress about their child and about parenting. Evidence: solid Whether five minutes a day on its own does that isn't known. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • 23 controlled trials, 1,144 people: the full programme cut children's behaviour problems by a large margin compared with control groups, lowered parents' stress, and children did more of what they were asked. Trials that coached parents until they'd mastered the skills did better than those that didn't. Evidence: solid
  • 100 mothers of three- to six-year-olds with defiance problems reported fewer behaviour problems and less stress after the play half of the programme. No comparison group. Evidence: worth trying
  • 24 families were given the two halves in different orders. At the halfway point, the discipline half had cut defiance and disruption more than the play half had. Evidence: worth trying
  • In 204 families involved with child welfare, more play sessions followed by more discipline sessions went with better parenting and fewer behaviour problems. The discipline half mattered too. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • Five minutes, once a day, whatever they pick.
  • You follow. Copy what they do, join in, describe it out loud.
  • No questions, no instructions, no teaching. The hard part is not asking questions. Try it once and you'll see.
  • Phone away.
  • With teenagers the version is: their music in the car, no comment. Untested. Evidence: worth trying

Watch out

The trials are with children roughly two to seven with real behaviour problems. Evidence: solid For an ordinary kid, or a teenager, treat it as a good habit rather than a treatment. Evidence: worth trying

The five minutes are half of a programme. The other half, calm and consistent discipline, did more for defiance in the one study that compared them head to head. Evidence: worth trying See the time-out that works and the one rule you hold.

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.