steady

Family · With the kids

Rough play, then a landing

10 minEvidence: worth trying

Do this

Wrestle or chase. They can call stop any time and you stop, every time; you keep the game from running away. Then land it together. Sit, slow down, a drink of water, before anything else.

How to do it

  1. Let them set the stop. When they say stop, you stop, every time.
  2. Keep the game from running away. You're the one who holds the frame.
  3. Land it. Sit, slow down, a drink of water, before anything else. Untested, just sensible.
  4. Do it because they like it. It isn't shown to build better kids.

How the game stays safe

  1. Excitementruns high

    Rough play is hot play. The researchers' idea is that kids have to keep themselves in check to keep the game going.

  2. Limitsyou hold the frame

    In 85 father-child pairs, lots of rough play went with more aggression only where the father kept less control of the game. A correlation.

  3. The stopyou stop, every time

    When they say stop, you stop. That's a rule of decency more than a research finding; the game rests on it.

  4. Landingback to calm

    Ending on a slow minute rather than a sudden stop. Not from the research; a sensible way down from a high.

Why it works

A review of 16 studies, 1,521 fathers and their kids, looked at rough-and-tumble play with fathers and found links with how the kids do. Evidence: worth trying Every one of those links is a correlation. Fathers who play like this may differ in other ways too, so nobody can say the play caused anything.

Do it because they like it.

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 2 min read.

What happens in your brain

Excitement runs high. Rough play is what researchers call hot play: fast, physical, close to the edge. Their idea is that to keep the game going, kids have to keep their own actions in check even in the heat of it. Evidence: worth trying That's their reading, not a measured effect.

You hold the frame. In a study that filmed 85 fathers playing with their two- to six-year-olds at home, more rough play went with more physical aggression in kids whose fathers kept less control of the game. Where the father stayed in charge of the play, that link wasn't there. Evidence: worth trying A correlation, one study.

The stop. The rule that matters is the stop. When they say stop, you stop. The whole game rests on that. It's a rule of decency, not a research finding.

The landing. The landing isn't from the research. Ending on a slow minute rather than a sudden stop is just a sensible way to come down from a high. Untested. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • 16 studies, 1,521 father-child pairs: rough play went with the kids' social skills, emotional skills and self-control, and with aggression, with weak to moderate links. Evidence: worth trying Only about a third of the children were boys. Evidence: decent
  • 85 father-child pairs, children two to six: more rough play went with more aggression only where the father was less in control of the play. The authors say themselves it's correlational. Evidence: worth trying

How to do it

  • Wrestle, chase, whatever they like.
  • When they say stop, you stop, every time.
  • Keep the game from running away. You're the one who holds the frame. Evidence: worth trying
  • Then land it together. Sit, slow down, a drink of water, before anything else.

Watch out

Every link in this research is a correlation, so nobody can say the play caused anything. Evidence: worth trying You'll see it sold as building better kids. The research doesn't show that. Evidence: worth trying

In one study, lots of rough play went with more aggression where the father kept less control. Evidence: worth trying Playing at their pace is fine; letting it run with no one in charge may not be.

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.