How to do it
- One word, plain. Annoyed, embarrassed, scared. The scan studies used single emotion words.
- Say it or write it. Speaking and picking a word from a list were both tested.
- Then leave it. You don't have to do anything with the word; naming is the whole move.
- Name the feeling, not the verdict. "Annoyed", not "he's an idiot". The spider study found more fear words went with a bigger drop.
In your brainTap a word for what it means
- PrefrontalPrefrontal cortexThe front part of the brain's outer layer, behind the forehead, sometimes called the brain's CEO. It handles planning, decisions, self-control and keeping emotions in check, and works worse when you are short on sleep.Read morefinds the word
Choosing a word for the emotion on a face made a patch on the right side of the prefrontal cortex more active. Choosing a name to fit the face didn't do the same.
- AmygdalaAmygdalaA small almond-shaped cluster of nerve cells, one deep in each side of the brain, often called the fear centre. It flags threats and other things that matter emotionally, including good ones, and can react before you have had time to think.Read moreturns down
The alarm was less active too. The busier the prefrontal patch, the quieter the alarm. A correlation; one modelling study suggests the prefrontal side drives it.
- Bodysweats less
In a separate study, people who named their fear next to a live spider had a smaller sweat response a week later. They didn't say they felt less scared.
- Youfeel it a bit less
People rated upsetting pictures as less bad when they labelled them. Most expected labelling to make it worse.
Why it works
Putting a feeling into a word turns down the brain's alarm response to it. Evidence: decent It doesn't feel like it should work. In lab studies people predicted that naming a bad feeling would make it worse, even straight after it had made it better. Evidence: decent
You don't have to do anything with the word. Naming is the intervention. It's also easier to be fair to someone else when you know what you're feeling yourself. Evidence: worth trying
The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 4 min read.
What happens in your brain
The front of the brain finds the word. In imaging studies, labelling an emotion raises activity in the part of the prefrontal cortex that keeps things in proportion, a patch on the right side called the ventrolateral prefrontal cortex. In the best-known scan study, people chose a word for the emotion on a face, and that patch was more active than when they chose a name that matched the face. Evidence: decent
The alarm turns down. In the same study, labelling lowered activity in the amygdala and other emotional areas. The more active the prefrontal patch, the quieter the amygdala. Evidence: decent That's a correlation. A later modelling study suggested the prefrontal side is what turns the amygdala down, but it's one analysis. Evidence: worth trying Scans track blood flow, so these areas were more or less active; nothing "switched off".
The body settles, later. In a separate study, people afraid of spiders stood near a live tarantula and either named their fear, reframed it, distracted themselves, or just stayed. A week later, with a different spider, the naming group had a smaller sweat response than every other group. Evidence: decent They didn't report feeling less scared. Evidence: decent
You feel it a bit less. Across studies, people rated upsetting pictures as less bad when they labelled them than when they only looked. Evidence: decent These are separate findings, from different people, not one traced pathway. That they add up to what happens when you say "annoyed" in a car park is an inference. Evidence: worth trying
The proof
- 39 adults aged 55 to 75 looked at grim photos in a scanner. When they picked a word for their own reaction, they rated the photos less unpleasant, and the amygdala was less active, than when they just looked. Evidence: decent
- 88 spider-fearful people were exposed to a live tarantula. Those who put their fear into words had a smaller sweat response a week later than those who reframed, distracted themselves, or were only exposed. Their own fear ratings didn't differ, and they only marginally out-approached the distraction group. Evidence: decent
- In three studies, labelling upsetting pictures cut reported distress, about as much as reframing or distraction did. In each, people predicted labelling would do the opposite. Evidence: decent
How to do it
- One word, plain. Annoyed, embarrassed, scared.
- Say it or write it. Speaking and choosing from a list of words have both been tested. Evidence: decent Writing hasn't been tested against a comparison group; the nearest is 74,487 Twitter users whose tweets turned less negative soon after they wrote that they felt bad, with no one to compare them with. Evidence: worth trying
- Then leave it. You don't have to do anything with the word.
- Name the feeling, not the verdict. "Annoyed", not "he's an idiot". In the spider study, the more fear and anxiety words people used, the bigger the drop. Evidence: decent
- If you'd rather say it to someone, say it out loud has one-line openers.
Watch out
Most of the brain evidence comes from people labelling faces and photos in a scanner, not their own feelings in the middle of a real row. That it carries over is an inference. Evidence: worth trying The studies were small, and most of the volunteers were women, many of them students. Evidence: decent
Labelling dulls good feelings too: in one study, naming the emotion in pleasant pictures lowered the pleasure people reported. Evidence: decent So use it on the bad moments, not the good ones.
In one study, rating your feelings during a task set up to make you angry changed the body's response; during one set up to shame you, it changed nothing. Evidence: decent Embarrassment may not respond the same way as anger. Evidence: worth trying
You may have seen it said that writing about your feelings "calms the amygdala". That's oversold. The scan studies here had people pick a word for a face or a photo, not write about their lives. Evidence: decent Writing studies measure something else, mood and health weeks after a few sessions of writing or talking about something hard, and across 146 such trials the average effect was small. Evidence: solid A later review of 31 trials found the small gain showed up at follow-up, not straight after. Evidence: solid One study joined the two: brain activity during word-labelling in a scanner predicted which of 111 students got more out of writing three months on, but nobody was scanned while writing. Evidence: worth trying Nobody has shown that writing calms the amygdala. Evidence: decent