steady

Relationships · When it turns into a fight

Write the fight as a referee

7 minEvidence: decent

Do this

After a bad row, once it's cooled: seven minutes writing how a neutral third party who wants the best for both of you would describe it. Three times a year is enough.

How to do it

  1. Wait until it's cooled. This is for after the row, not during it.
  2. Write as a neutral person who wants the best for both of you. How would they see it? What good could come of it?
  3. Seven minutes, then stop. The trial used seven, every four months.
  4. End with a plan. What gets in the way of that view mid-row, and how you'll hold it next time.

How stepping back helpsTap a word for what it means

  1. Ruminationreplays your side

    Going back over a row from inside your own head keeps the anger hot. Looking at it from outside lets you think about it without reliving it.

  2. Prefrontalreframes the fight

    Across 48 scan studies, reinterpreting a bad moment used the front of the brain and turned the amygdala down. They mostly used pictures; that the referee's view works the same way is an inference.

  3. Distressfades between rows

    In the trial, the writing worked by cutting how upset people stayed about their fights.

  4. You twostop the slide

    Marriage quality held level in the year of writing. Couples who didn't write kept declining.

Why it works

It doesn't make things great. It stops the slow slide. Evidence: decent Writing from the outside pulls you out of your own corner long enough to see the shape of the fight, and the shape is usually the same every time. Evidence: worth trying

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.

What happens in your brain

From inside, the row replays. Thinking a fight over from inside your own head tends to bring the anger back each time. That's rumination. In two experiments, people who recalled an anger-making episode from a distance, as an observer asking why it happened, felt less upset than people who relived it. Evidence: decent

From outside, you reason better. In three experiments with 693 people, younger and older, people reasoned more wisely about someone else's relationship conflict than their own: they saw more sides, allowed for compromise and for things changing. Told to step back and see their own conflict from a distance, the gap closed. Evidence: decent

The front of the brain reframes it. Changing how you read a situation is called reappraisal. Across 48 brain-scan studies, it consistently used control areas in the prefrontal cortex and turned down activity in the amygdala. Evidence: decent Those studies mostly used upsetting pictures, not written-up rows, so applying them here is an inference. Evidence: worth trying

The sting fades, and the marriage holds. In the trial, the writing worked by lowering how angry and upset people stayed about their conflicts, and that is what kept marriage quality from sliding. Evidence: decent

The proof

  • In a two-year study of 120 married couples, half did this in the second year: three times, seven minutes each, four months apart. The other half did nothing extra. Both groups slid in marriage quality over the first year, the way most couples do. In the second year the do-nothing couples kept sliding. The writing couples stopped. Evidence: decent
  • The whole thing took 21 minutes over a year, and its effect ran through less distress about conflict. Marriage quality there combined satisfaction, love, intimacy, trust, passion and commitment. Evidence: decent
  • 693 people across three experiments reasoned more wisely about others' conflicts than their own. Self-distancing removed the difference. Evidence: decent
  • Two experiments: looking back on an anger episode from a distance, asking why, left people less upset than reliving it up close. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • Wait until it's cooled. This is for after, not during. Evidence: worth trying
  • Write about the latest disagreement as a neutral third party who wants the best for both of you. How would they think about it? What good could they see coming from it? Those were the trial's own questions. Evidence: decent
  • Seven minutes, then stop. Three times a year is what was tested. Evidence: decent
  • Finish with two questions the trial also asked: what gets in the way of that view mid-row, and how you'll hold it over the next few months. Evidence: decent
  • The write it out tool gives you a page to do it on.

Watch out

It stopped a decline; it didn't lift anyone above where they started. Evidence: decent It's one trial, with married couples, and nobody knows how long the effect lasts past the year tested. Evidence: decent If there's fear or control in the relationship, this is the wrong tool: talk to someone outside it.

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.