steady

Relationships · When it turns into a fight

Argue their side for a minute

1 minEvidence: decent

Do this

When someone's got you angry, spend one minute making their case as if you meant it.

How to do it

  1. One minute, their case, as if you meant it. In your head or on paper.
  2. Work out what they want, not only how they feel. Their thinking helped; sympathy alone didn't.
  3. You don't have to agree afterwards. You have to have understood.
  4. Then talk. The minute comes before the conversation, not instead of it.

In your brainTap a word for what it means

  1. Amygdalasounds the alarm

    Anger starts fast and narrows attention onto the threat. That in a row this means your own side is my reading.

  2. Prefrontalrewrites the story

    Across 48 scan studies, reinterpreting a bad moment used the front of the brain and turned the amygdala down. They mostly used pictures; that making their case works the same way is an inference.

  3. Your viewwidens to theirs

    Partners asked to take the other's view reacted less negatively, blamed less and leaned towards a calmer reply.

  4. You twofind the way out

    People who worked out the other side's thinking found hidden deals far more often. Those were negotiators, not couples; carrying it home is an inference.

Why it works

Anger narrows the view to your own side. Evidence: worth trying Deliberately taking the other person's viewpoint widens it again, and in studies it lowers your own distress and makes a calmer, more constructive reply more likely. Evidence: decent

You don't have to agree afterwards. You have to have understood. Plenty of fights are two people who never did the minute. Evidence: worth trying

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 2 min read.

What happens in your brain

The alarm goes off. The amygdala spots threat and readies the body before you've thought, and attention narrows onto whatever set it off. Evidence: decent In a row, what set it off is them, so your own side is all you see. That last step is my reading, not a measured result. Evidence: worth trying

The front of the brain rewrites the story. Changing how you read a situation is called reappraisal. Across 48 brain-scan studies, it consistently used control areas in the prefrontal cortex and turned down activity in the amygdala. Evidence: decent Arguing their side is one way of reappraising; those studies mostly used upsetting pictures, not partners. Evidence: worth trying

Your view widens. In four studies of married and dating partners, people who took their partner's perspective during a moment when the partner behaved badly felt less negative, blamed the partner less and were more inclined to respond constructively than people who kept their own view. Three of them assigned the perspective at random. Evidence: decent

You find the way out. In a classroom negotiation over selling a petrol station, the deal only worked if the two sides found a hidden option. Buyers told to think about what the seller wanted closed 76% of the time; buyers given no instruction, 39%. Evidence: decent

The proof

  • Four studies with married and dating partners: taking the partner's perspective led to more positive and less negative feelings, less blame, and more willingness to respond constructively. Evidence: decent
  • In a negotiation experiment, pairs with a buyer told to take the seller's perspective reached a deal 76% of the time, against 39% for pairs with no instruction. Buyers told to feel for the seller did no better than the controls. Evidence: decent
  • A review of 48 brain-scan studies: reinterpreting a bad situation used the brain's control areas and reduced amygdala activity. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • One minute, their case, as if you meant it. In your head, out loud to yourself, or on paper. Evidence: worth trying
  • Work out what they want and why, not only how they feel. In the negotiation study, thinking their way through helped; feeling for them alone didn't. Evidence: decent
  • You don't have to agree afterwards. You have to have understood.
  • Then talk. The minute is for before the conversation, not instead of it. Evidence: worth trying

Watch out

The deal numbers come from students negotiating in a class, not couples mid-row. Evidence: decent The couple studies measured feelings and intentions, not what happened in the next fight. Evidence: decent Understanding their case isn't agreeing with it, and it doesn't mean putting up with being mistreated. If there's fear or control in the relationship, this is the wrong tool: talk to someone outside it.

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.