steady

Stress and nerves · Money

Say the number to one person

5 minEvidence: worth trying

Do this

Tell one person you trust the actual figure you owe or are short by. Not "things are tight". The number.

How to do it

  1. The number, not "things are tight". A vague version keeps the real one a secret.
  2. Pick someone who won't lecture you and won't reach for their wallet on the spot. Confiding went with feeling able to cope only when it brought support.
  3. You're not asking for anything. You're just not carrying it alone.
  4. If the number is past what you can handle, the second person to tell is a free, independent debt adviser.

How the secret loosens

  1. Secretpulls you back

    People's minds went back to their secrets far more often than they ever had to hide them. The more often, the lower their well-being.

  2. Confidingone person knows

    Secrets people had told someone went with feeling more able to cope. It didn't mean hiding it less from everyone else.

  3. Supportmakes it count

    That held only when telling brought real support. With almost none, confiding went with feeling less able to cope.

  4. Youit's a number again

    That saying the exact figure beats "things are tight" is my bet. Nobody has tested it.

Why it works

No study behind this exact move. Evidence: worth trying

My bet: a number nobody else knows gets bigger in your head than it is on paper. Once you've said it out loud, it's back to being a number.

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 2 min read.

What happens in your brain

A secret pulls your mind back. Across ten studies and more than 13,000 secrets, people caught themselves thinking about their secrets far more often than they were ever in a situation where they had to hide them. The more often their minds went back to a secret, the lower their well-being. Evidence: decent Finances were one of the 38 common kinds of secret the researchers asked about. Evidence: decent

One person knowing changes how you hold it. In four studies of 800 people and over 10,000 secrets, the ones people had told someone went with feeling more able to cope, and through that with the secret coming to mind less often. Confiding didn't mean hiding it less from everyone else. Evidence: decent

It depends who you tell. That link held when telling brought real support: comfort, advice, a new way of seeing it. When confiding brought almost no support, it went with feeling less able to cope. Evidence: decent

It's a number again. That the exact figure does more than "things are tight" is my bet, not a finding. Evidence: worth trying Most of this research is correlation: people who confided may differ from people who didn't. Evidence: decent

The proof

  • Ten studies, more than 13,000 secrets: minds wandered to secrets far more often than people had to conceal them, and that mind-wandering went with lower well-being. Evidence: decent
  • Four studies, 800 people, over 10,000 secrets: confided secrets went with more sense of being able to cope, and through that with less mind-wandering to them. Evidence: decent
  • In one of those, 200 people: confiding went with feeling more able to cope when it brought support. At the lowest support it went with feeling less able. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • Tell one person you trust the actual figure you owe or are short by. Not "things are tight". The number.
  • Pick someone who won't lecture you and won't reach for their wallet on the spot. A partner, a brother, the friend who's been short himself.
  • You're not asking for anything. You're just not carrying it alone.

The wider case for having one person in the loop is in Fighting your battles alone.

Watch out

The secrets research covers secrets of every kind, not debt in particular. Evidence: decent Choose the person: confiding that brought little support went with feeling less able to cope. Evidence: decent

If the number is past what you can handle, the second person to tell is a free, independent debt adviser. Not one that charges you, and not one selling you a loan.

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.