How to do it
- One, not the pile. Pick the one you've avoided longest.
- Write down the number you think is in it. It gives you something to check the real one against.
- Open it now, not tonight. In the lab, some people took a stronger shock just to cut the wait.
- Once it's open, it's a number. You can plan around a number; you can't plan around a closed envelope.
Why not knowing costs more
- Bad newsyou look away
When the news is likely to be bad, people check less. Investors logged in less after market falls, and the pull was stronger in men.
- Uncertaintykeeps stress up
In a lab task, stress, sweating and pupil size tracked how unpredictable a coming shock was. Shocks, not bills; applying it here is a guess.
- Dreadmakes waiting cost
Most people chose to get a shock over with sooner, and some took a stronger one rather than wait. A separate finding from the ones above.
- Youplan around a number
Checking where you stand helped people reach goals in many trials. Opening one bill wasn't among them; that step is a guess.
Why it works
When the news is likely to be bad, people look less. Economists call it the ostrich effect. Evidence: decent Not knowing and waiting both carry their own strain, separate from the bad news itself. Evidence: decent That the same applies to an envelope on the side is my assumption. Evidence: worth trying
One. Not the pile. Once it's open, it's a number, and you can plan around a number. You can't plan around a closed envelope.
The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.
What happens in your brain
Bad news, you look away. Investors logged into their accounts less often after the market fell. In a larger study of retirement savings accounts, logins dropped by 9.5 per cent after a fall. Evidence: decent The pull was stronger in men and in wealthier investors. Evidence: decent
Those studies are about investments, not bills or bank balances, and they were worked out from when people logged in, not from asking them why. That the same pull keeps the envelope closed on the side is my assumption. Evidence: worth trying
Not knowing keeps you on edge. In a lab study, 45 people learned which of two pictures tended to come before a painful shock. Their stress ratings, sweating and pupil size tracked how unpredictable the shock was, and unpredictability is greatest when it's close to a coin toss. Evidence: decent That was shocks in a lab. A closed envelope is uncertainty of a different kind, so the link is a guess. Evidence: worth trying
Waiting costs something too. In a brain-scan study, 32 people waited for electric shocks. Offered the same shock sooner or later, 27 of them mostly chose sooner, and 9 would take a stronger shock rather than wait longest. In those 9, activity in areas that process pain rose faster while they waited. Evidence: decent The authors read that as dread: attention going to what's coming. Evidence: decent
These are separate findings, not one tested pathway. Putting them together for a bill is my reading. Evidence: worth trying
A number you can plan around. Across 138 trials with 19,951 people, getting people to check their progress towards a goal helped them reach it, and it helped more when they wrote the information down. Evidence: decent None of those trials was about opening a bill. Evidence: worth trying
Writing a guess first is my addition, and untested. It gives you something to check the real number against. Evidence: worth trying
The proof
- Daily logins from 100,000 randomly chosen retirement accounts, 2007 and 2008: logins fell 9.5 per cent after market declines. Evidence: decent
- In two datasets, Scandinavian and American investors looked at their portfolios more when markets were rising than when they were flat or falling. Evidence: decent
- 32 people waiting for shocks in a scanner: 27 mostly chose to get an equal shock sooner, and 9 were willing to take a stronger one to avoid the longest wait. Evidence: decent
- 45 people in a shock-learning task: stress ratings, sweating and pupil size followed how unpredictable the shocks were. Evidence: decent
- 138 randomised studies, 19,951 people: prompting people to monitor their progress raised goal attainment, more so when progress was physically recorded. Evidence: decent
How to do it
- One. Not the pile. Pick the one you've avoided longest.
- Write down the number you think is in it. Evidence: worth trying
- Open it now. The waiting is part of what makes it heavy. Evidence: worth trying
- Once it's open, it's a number, and you can plan around a number.
Watch out
The login studies are about investments, not bills or bank balances. Evidence: decent In the investor data, people who looked less in falling markets also traded less then. The authors suggest that may have kept some of them from overreacting to the fall. Evidence: decent A bill doesn't work like that: it's still there when you open it. Evidence: worth trying
If the number is more than you can see a way through, talk to a free, independent debt advice service before you do anything else. Not one that charges you, and not one selling you a loan.