How to do it
- Pick one bill or one small transfer. One is enough to start.
- Set it for the day your pay lands. The money leaves before you can think about it.
- Keep the amount small enough that it always clears. A payment that bounces is a new thing to worry about.
- Check it once a year. Defaults stick, and the amount you set today may be too low next year.
How the loop closes
- Open loopkeeps nagging
In lab studies, a goal left unfinished kept intruding on unrelated tasks. A bill you pay by hand each month is one of those.
- Defaultdoes it for you
Whatever is set up to happen tends to keep happening. Most people left an automatic savings plan exactly as it was set.
- Plancloses the loop
In the same lab studies, making a specific plan for the unfinished goal stopped the intrusions.
- Youone less thing
That a standing order frees up room in a full head is a guess. The studies tested lab goals and workplace pensions, not your bills.
Why it works
What's set up to happen by itself tends to keep happening. When a large US employer signed new staff up for the retirement savings plan automatically, with the option to leave, the share of people saving rose sharply. Evidence: solid In a related scheme, people agreed in advance to put part of their future pay rises into savings, and they saved more. Evidence: decent
Both were studied in US workplaces, with the employer setting it up. A standing order you set yourself is the same idea, not the same test. Evidence: worth trying
My reason for putting it on this page isn't the savings. It's one less thing to decide when your head is already full. Evidence: worth trying
The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.
What happens in your brain
An open loop keeps nagging. In a set of lab studies, a goal people had been reminded of and hadn't finished kept coming back: it intruded while they read something unrelated and dragged down their score on a word puzzle. Evidence: decent A bill you pay by hand every month is that kind of unfinished goal. That's a reasonable step, not a test. Evidence: worth trying
The default does it for you. Whatever is already set tends to win. At the US firm, most new staff not only stayed in the plan but kept the exact contribution rate and fund the company had picked. Evidence: solid The authors put it down to inertia, and to people reading the default as advice. Evidence: decent
A plan closes the loop. In the same lab studies, letting people write a specific plan for the unfinished goal stopped the intrusions and the drag on the puzzle, even though the goal itself was still undone. Evidence: decent Setting up an automatic payment is about as specific as a plan gets. Evidence: worth trying
You carry one less thing. That the boring payment then stops taking up room is the idea, and it hasn't been measured for bills. Evidence: worth trying The popular version, that every decision drains a fixed tank of willpower, didn't hold up: two large repeat studies across dozens of labs found little or no effect. Evidence: solid
The proof
- At one large US company, 37% of employees hired under the old sign-up-yourself rules had joined the retirement plan after 3 to 15 months. Under automatic enrollment, 86% of new hires with similar time in the job were in. Evidence: solid
- 61% of the automatically enrolled staff stayed exactly at the default: a low 3% contribution, all of it in a money market fund. Evidence: solid
- In the first Save More Tomorrow scheme, at one company, 78% of the staff offered it joined, and their average saving rate went from 3.5% to 13.6% over 40 months as it rose with each pay rise. Evidence: decent
- A meta-analysis of 58 studies with over 73,000 people found defaults had a sizeable effect on what people chose, but not every study found one, and two found the opposite. Evidence: solid
How to do it
- Pick one bill or one small transfer. One is enough to start. Evidence: worth trying
- Set it for the day your pay lands, so the money leaves before you have to decide anything. Evidence: worth trying
- Keep the amount small enough that it always clears. The point is that you never think about it.
- Look at it once a year. Defaults stick: most people in the workplace study stayed at the low starting rate. Evidence: solid
Watch out
The evidence is from US workplace pension schemes, set up by the employer. Evidence: solid Your own standing order is the same idea, untested. Evidence: worth trying Defaults can hold you at a bad level as easily as a good one. Evidence: decent
None of this is financial advice. If the debt has gone past what you can see a way through, or gambling is part of it, talk to a free, independent debt advice service. Not one that charges you, and not one selling you a loan.