steady

Stress and nerves · Money

Check the account on a schedule, not a mood

10 minEvidence: worth trying

Do this

Pick one fixed time a week to look at your bank account. Sunday after breakfast, say. Put it in the calendar and look then, whatever you expect to see.

How to do it

  1. Pick one time a week and put it in the calendar. The calendar decides, not the mood.
  2. Look then, whatever you expect. The weeks you least want to look are the ones that matter.
  3. Ten minutes. Balance, what's gone out, what's coming. Then close it.
  4. In between, leave it. You know when you'll look next.

Why you stop looking

  1. Bad newsmakes you look away

    People logged in to their savings less after the market fell, and to their bank app less once they were overdrawn.

  2. Reliefpays you for not looking

    In a money game, dodging a loss made a reward area more active, as winning did. That the same happens when you don't open the app is a guess.

  3. Calendardecides in advance

    Deciding when and where you'll do something, ahead of time, helped people follow through across dozens of studies.

  4. Youstop half-thinking

    In lab studies, a specific plan stopped an unfinished goal intruding on other tasks. That a weekly slot does this for money is untested.

Why it works

People check their accounts less when things look bad. In a large study of retirement savings accounts, logins dropped by 9.5 per cent after the market fell. Evidence: decent A study of bank app data found the same with everyday accounts: people looked less once they were overdrawn. Evidence: decent Check when you feel like it and you'll look least when it matters most. Evidence: worth trying

A fixed time takes the feeling out of the decision. Same idea as three checks a day for the phone: the calendar decides, not the mood. Evidence: worth trying

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 2 min read.

What happens in your brain

Bad news makes you look away. In 100,000 US retirement accounts over two years, logins fell 9.5 per cent after the market went down. Evidence: decent In bank data from Iceland, people logged in less when their account went from positive to overdrawn, and less still as the overdraft grew; they logged in more when pay arrived. Evidence: decent The researchers call it the ostrich effect: avoiding information because it might feel bad. Evidence: decent

Relief pays you for not looking. In a scan study of 16 people playing a money game, avoiding a loss made a reward area just behind the eyes more active, the same way winning money did. Evidence: decent That not opening the banking app works the same way is a guess. Evidence: worth trying

The calendar decides in advance. Across 94 tests, people who decided ahead of time when and where they would act followed through on their goals better than people who only intended to. The average effect was medium to large. Evidence: solid

You stop half-thinking about it. In a set of lab studies, a goal left unfinished kept intruding on unrelated tasks, and making a specific plan for it stopped that. Evidence: decent That a weekly slot does the same for money worry hasn't been tested. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • Daily logins in 100,000 US retirement savings accounts, 2007 to 2008: logins fell 9.5 per cent after market declines. Evidence: decent
  • Bank data from a money-management app in Iceland: attention dropped when accounts went overdrawn and dropped further as the overdraft grew. Evidence: decent
  • A meta-analysis of 94 tests found that deciding in advance when, where and how to act improved goal attainment, with a medium to large effect on average. Evidence: solid
  • Across six lab studies, unfinished goals caused intrusive thoughts and worse performance on unrelated tasks, and writing a specific plan for the goal removed those effects. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • Pick one time a week and put it in the calendar. Sunday after breakfast, say. Evidence: worth trying
  • Look then, whatever you expect to see. The weeks you least want to look are the ones that matter. Evidence: worth trying
  • Ten minutes: balance, what's gone out, what's coming. Then close it.
  • In between, you don't have to keep half-thinking about it. You know when you'll look. Evidence: worth trying

Watch out

Nobody has tested a fixed weekly check on bank accounts. The looking-away is measured. The fix is borrowed from research on plans in general. Evidence: worth trying

None of this is financial advice. If the debt has gone past what you can see a way through, or gambling is part of it, talk to a free, independent debt advice service. Not one that charges you, and not one selling you a loan.

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.