steady

Mood · In your head

Expect less, enjoy more

Evidence: worth trying

Do this

Before a night out, a holiday or a new job, look forward to it, but don't script how good it'll be. Expect decent, not the best in years.

How to do it

  1. Look forward to it. Waiting on a good result lifted mood by itself; don't give that up.
  2. Drop the script. A night out: expect a good evening with them, not the best in months. A holiday: some rain, one bad meal. A new job: an ordinary first month.
  3. Plan it well, forecast it modestly. Aim high on what you do; keep the guess of how it'll feel plain.
  4. Not on people. Expecting little of your partner isn't this.

In your brainTap a word for what it means

  1. Dopaminesignals the gap

    In monkeys, dopamine cells fired for rewards better than predicted, stayed flat for ones as good as predicted, and dipped for worse.

  2. Striatumfollows the same sums

    In 24 people's scans during a betting game, activity here tracked expectations and surprises and went with how happy they said they were next. A test of whether it carries the effect came up short.

  3. Happinessrises with the gap

    Moment to moment, it followed recent expectations and surprises, not money won. Looking forward to a good result lifted it too.

  4. Youenjoy small things more

    A lower bar makes a good surprise more likely. That this works on a weekend or a meal is a guess; nobody has tested it.

Why it works

Dopamine cells don't track how good something is so much as the gap between what you expected and what you got. Same dinner, lower expectation, bigger surprise. That part is textbook, from decades of animal work. Evidence: solid In people, a betting game showed happiness moving the same way: with expectations and surprises, not with how much people had won. Evidence: decent

Using it on purpose in daily life is a neuroscientist's personal habit, not a studied intervention. Evidence: worth trying

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.

What happens in your brain

Dopamine signals the gap. In monkeys, most dopamine cells fire for a reward that's better than predicted, stay flat for one that's exactly as good as predicted, and dip for one that's worse. Evidence: solid It works as a teaching signal: it tells the brain its forecast was off. Evidence: solid

The striatum follows the same sums. In 24 usable scans of people choosing between safe and risky money options, activity in the ventral striatum, a main target of dopamine cells, followed expectations and surprises, and went with how happy people said they were next. Evidence: decent The scans track blood flow, not dopamine. And a direct test of whether striatum activity carries the link to happiness wasn't significant. Evidence: decent

Happiness rises with the gap. A model built on those same terms explained people's moment-to-moment happiness better than one built on money won. Recent expectations mattered as well as surprises: choosing a gamble that might pay well lifted mood before the result. Evidence: decent

You enjoy small things more. Lower the bar and a decent result is more likely to beat it. That this carries over from a betting game to a weekend or a meal is a guess. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • In the lab, 26 people played a betting game for prizes of up to £3 and rated their happiness every two or three rounds. Their ratings were explained by recent expectations and surprises, not by their total earnings. Evidence: decent
  • 18,420 unpaid, anonymous people played a version of the same game on a smartphone app. Same result. Evidence: decent
  • The effect is short. In the model, for a player with the lab group's average fade rate, a win five rounds back had about 8 per cent of the pull of a win just now; with a slower or faster fade, 33 or 1 per cent. Evidence: decent
  • An independent, preregistered repeat of the lab study mostly confirmed the findings. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • Look forward to it. In the model, looking forward to a good result lifted mood by itself, and the authors point out that low expectations cost you that. Evidence: decent
  • Drop the script of how good it'll be. Before a night out, expect a good evening with people you like, not the best night in months. Before a holiday, expect some rain and one bad meal. Before a new job, expect the first month to be ordinary. Evidence: worth trying
  • Plan it well and forecast it modestly. That's the neuroscientist's own version: aim high, expect little, so a miss is fine and a hit feels big. Evidence: worth trying
  • Not on people. Expecting little of your partner isn't this.

This sits fine next to book it further out. Look forward to the day; just don't decide in advance how great it'll be. In the model, the lift before and the letdown after come from the same expectation, so pulling them apart like this is my reading, not the paper's. Evidence: worth trying

Watch out

The happiness data come from a gambling task with small sums, measured over minutes. Nobody has tested lowering your expectations for real life. Evidence: decent Low expectations also mean less pleasure beforehand, which limits how much this can give you. Evidence: decent And the dopamine story comes from animals and from scans that track blood flow; dopamine itself wasn't measured in these people. Evidence: decent

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.