steady

Happiness · Reading yourself right

Don't make happy the goal

1 weekEvidence: worth trying

Do this

This week, pick one thing for itself, a job to finish or a person to see. Do it, and don't stop halfway to ask if you're happy yet.

How to do it

  1. Pick the thing, not the feeling. Fix the bike brakes, cook the proper meal, see the friend you keep putting off.
  2. Name it by what gets done. "Brakes fixed" can be finished; "a good Saturday" can only be graded.
  3. Catch the check-in. When "am I enjoying this yet?" comes up halfway, go back to the task.
  4. Wanting a good life is fine. What carried the drop was disappointment with their own feelings.

How chasing it backfires

  1. Prizing itraises the stakes

    In one study, some women were first led to put a high value on happiness. Then everyone watched a happy film.

  2. Disappointmentcreeps in

    The ones nudged to prize happiness enjoyed the film less. Their disappointment accounted for the gap.

  3. Everyday lifelower well-being

    In a survey of women, valuing happiness more went with lower well-being, but only when life was calm. A link, not a cause.

  4. Youaim at the thing

    Doing something for its own sake and letting the mood follow is my reading of this. Nobody has tested it.

Why it works

Put happiness at the top of the list and you may start grading everything against it. Evidence: worth trying In one study, women who were first led to value happiness more then watched a happy film, and enjoyed it less than women who hadn't been nudged. Their disappointment explained the gap. Evidence: decent In a survey of women, valuing happiness more went with lower well-being, but only when life was fairly calm. Evidence: decent

So aim at something else and let the mood come along or not. That step is mine. Evidence: worth trying It's close to expecting less: a high bar leaves less room to be pleased. Evidence: worth trying

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 2 min read.

What happens in your brain

This chain is behaviour, not brain areas. The first three stops are one paper; the last is mine.

Prizing it raises the stakes. Some women were first led to put a high value on happiness. Then everyone watched a happy film. Evidence: decent

Disappointment creeps in. The ones nudged to prize happiness enjoyed the film less, and their disappointment accounted for it. Evidence: decent

Everyday life, lower well-being. In a survey of women, valuing happiness more went with lower well-being under low stress. A link, not a cause. Evidence: decent

You aim at the thing. Something worth doing for its own sake, with the mood as a side effect. Untested. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • Mauss, Tamir, Anderson and Savino, 2011: in study 1, women who valued happiness more reported lower well-being, but only under low stress. Evidence: decent In study 2, women led to value happiness enjoyed a happy film less, through disappointment. Evidence: decent
  • Ford and colleagues, 2015: chasing happiness went with lower well-being in the US, no difference in Germany, and higher well-being in Russia and East Asia. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • Pick the thing, not the feeling: fix the bike brakes, cook the proper meal, see the friend you keep putting off. Evidence: worth trying
  • Name it by what gets done. "Brakes fixed" can be finished; "a good Saturday" can only be graded. Evidence: worth trying
  • Catch the check-in. When "am I enjoying this yet?" comes up halfway, go back to the task. That's the question I'd leave out. Evidence: worth trying
  • Keep the bar modest on the fun stuff. Expect less covers why. Evidence: worth trying
  • Wanting a good life is fine. What carried the drop in the film study was disappointment with their own feelings. Evidence: decent

Watch out

Both studies in the main paper were of women only, and the survey link showed only under low stress. Evidence: decent Across countries, chasing happiness went with lower well-being in the US, no difference in Germany, and higher well-being in Russia and East Asia. Evidence: decent The survey is a link, not a cause, and the film study was one lab session. Evidence: decent

"Never think about being happy" is the oversold version. Nothing here says don't want it. Doing things for their own sake is my reading, not a tested method. Evidence: worth trying

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.