How to do it
- Price it in hours. An extra hour a day is five a week, most of a working day.
- Then ask what the extra pay buys back. In Germany, on average, it didn't cover it.
- Pick the reliable route over the fast one. Unpredictable commutes went with more stress.
- Stuck with it? Walk part of it, or use it on a person. Walking to work went with less strain; talking to a stranger made the ride nicer.
What the commute costsTap a word for what it means
- CortisolCortisolThe main stress hormone, a steroid made by the adrenal glands on top of the kidneys. It raises blood sugar, damps inflammation and readies the body for demand, and it peaks soon after you wake.Read morerises on the way in
In 208 rail commuters into Manhattan, the longer the ride, the bigger the rise in the stress hormone above their resting level.
- Unpredictablegoes with more stress
Rail commuters who found their trip less predictable felt more stressed and had more cortisol. That this is why you don't get used to it is a guess.
- Free timefeels squeezed
In over 26,000 workers in England, the strongest link with a longer commute was less satisfaction with free time.
- Youpay for it
In Germany, the pay or the house at the other end didn't make up for it. In England, overall it roughly did. Both are links, not tests.
Why it works
In years of German panel data, people with longer commutes were less satisfied with life, and the extra pay or bigger house at the other end didn't make up for it. Economists called it the commuting paradox: people take the trade and it doesn't pay off. Evidence: decent
Observational, and the British data only partly agree: there, longer commutes went with less satisfaction with free time, more strain and poorer mental health, but not with lower overall life satisfaction. Evidence: decent Either way, the commute is a cost, and it rarely shows up in the salary sum. Evidence: worth trying
The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.
What happens in your brain
These are separate findings, lined up. Nobody has traced the whole chain in one person.
Your stress hormone rises on the way in. In 208 suburban rail commuters travelling into Manhattan, the longer the ride, the bigger the rise in cortisol in their saliva compared with their resting level. They also gave up sooner on a task at the end of the trip and felt more stressed. Evidence: decent
Unpredictability goes with more stress. In a smaller study of rail commuters, those who found their commute less predictable felt more stressed and had higher cortisol. Evidence: decent One guess at why you don't get used to it: it's different traffic every time. Evidence: worth trying The German researchers point out that people don't get used to random noise either, but do get used to a higher income. Evidence: decent
Free time feels squeezed. In over 26,000 workers in England, surveyed yearly for six years, a longer commute went with less satisfaction with free time, less with the job, more strain and poorer mental health. The link with free time was the strongest. Evidence: decent
You pay for it. In Germany, it wasn't made up by pay, housing or a partner's situation. Evidence: decent In England, overall life satisfaction didn't drop, except for people who kept a long commute for all six years. Evidence: decent
The proof
- German panel survey, 1985 to 2003: the average one-way commute was 22 minutes. People with longer commutes reported lower life satisfaction, and the authors estimated the average commute would take roughly a third more monthly pay to make up. They say not to lean on the exact number. Evidence: decent
- The effect of 18 extra minutes each way was about an eighth of the effect of losing your job. Evidence: decent
- Over 26,000 workers in England: longer commutes went with less satisfaction with free time and work, more strain and poorer mental health, but not lower life satisfaction overall. Walking to work went with more satisfaction with free time and less strain. Evidence: decent
- 208 rail commuters: longer rides, bigger cortisol rise, less persistence on a task afterwards, more stress. Evidence: decent
- In a study of 909 working women who rated each part of their day, the commute came last of 16 activities. Evidence: decent
How to do it
- Comparing two jobs, or two houses: price the commute. An extra hour a day is five hours a week, most of a working day gone.
- Ask what the extra pay buys. In the German data, on average, it didn't buy the time back. Evidence: decent
- Given a choice, take the more predictable route. Evidence: worth trying
- If you can't change it, make it count: a call to a friend, a language, an audiobook. Not the news. Evidence: worth trying Commuters told to talk to the person next to them enjoyed the ride more. Evidence: decent
Watch out
Observational, all of it. People with long commutes may differ in ways the data can't see. Evidence: decent In British panel data, the paradox mostly didn't show up in overall life satisfaction, only in free time, strain and mental health. Evidence: decent One British study found the mental health cost fell on women, not men, and linked it to women doing more of the housework and childcare. Evidence: decent The cortisol studies were small and on trains only. Evidence: decent