steady

Focus and work · The phone

Three checks, not three hundred

5 minEvidence: decent

Do this

Batch your notifications into three deliveries a day (on iPhone, the scheduled summary; on Android, a batching app). Calls and one person still come through. Check messages and feeds at those three times.

How to do it

  1. Set up the batching for three times that fit the day. An app batching the alerts is what the trial tested; it used 9am, 3pm and 9pm.
  2. Keep calls and one person coming through. Cutting everything off raised anxiety in the trial.
  3. Tell the people who expect fast answers. The trial couldn't change what others expected.
  4. Expect some pull to check in between. Even the batched group worried more about missing things.

How batching helpsTap a word for what it means

  1. Dopaminefires for the maybe

    In monkeys, dopamine cells ramped up most when a reward was a 50/50 chance. That a buzz works the same way on you is a guess.

  2. Alertsbreak your attention

    In a week with alerts on and the phone in reach, 221 people reported more inattention than in a week with alerts off and the phone away.

  3. Batchesfewer breaks

    With notifications in three daily batches, people unlocked less and felt more attentive. Less inattention went with most of the other gains.

  4. Youcalmer, not cut off

    The batched group felt less stressed and more in control. Switching notifications off entirely raised anxiety instead.

Why it works

Every buzz is a cue, and a cue you answer becomes a habit. Evidence: decent In a two-week trial, people whose notifications were batched into three deliveries a day felt less stressed, more attentive and more in control than people getting them as they came. Evidence: decent

The surprise in that trial: turning notifications off completely didn't help. People got more anxious, and the anxiety went with fear of missing things. Evidence: decent Three fixed times gave the benefit without the worry. Evidence: decent

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.

What happens in your brain

Dopamine fires for the maybe. In monkeys, dopamine cells showed a slow ramp of activity that was biggest when a reward was a 50/50 chance. Evidence: decent The trial's authors compare notifications to a slot machine. That a buzz works on you the same way is a guess; nobody has measured it. Evidence: worth trying

Alerts break your attention. 221 people spent a week with alerts on and the phone within reach, and a week with alerts off and the phone away. They reported more inattention with alerts on. Evidence: decent

Batches mean fewer breaks. In the batching trial, the three-a-day group unlocked their phones less and felt more attentive and better able to concentrate than the usual-delivery group. Evidence: decent Less inattention went with most of the other gains, in stress, mood and feeling productive. That link is statistical, not proven cause and effect. Evidence: decent

You're calmer, not cut off. The batched group felt less stressed and more in control of their phone. Evidence: decent The group that got no notifications at all didn't get more attentive, and felt more anxious. Evidence: decent

The proof

  • 237 smartphone users in India had their notifications delivered as usual, in a batch every hour, in three batches a day (9am, 3pm, 9pm), or not at all, for two weeks. The three-a-day group reported less stress, better attention and mood, and more control, and unlocked their phones less. Evidence: decent
  • Hourly batches made almost no difference compared with the usual stream. Evidence: decent
  • The no-notifications group felt less interrupted but no more attentive, and reported more anxiety than the usual group. Fear of missing things went with that anxiety. Evidence: decent
  • 124 adults spent one week checking email three times a day and one week checking as often as they could. Daily stress was lower in the limited week. They actually managed about five checks a day, against about twelve in the other week. Evidence: decent
  • In that email study, how stressful people remembered the week being didn't change. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • Set up the batching for three times that fit the day: after breakfast, after lunch, when work ends. In the trial an app did the batching, at 9am, 3pm and 9pm. Evidence: decent
  • Leave calls and one person coming through. Cutting everything off raised anxiety in the trial. Evidence: decent
  • The trial batched notifications; extending it to feeds is my addition. Evidence: worth trying Either way, the phone stops deciding when your attention moves.
  • Tell the people who expect fast answers when you'll look. The trial couldn't change what others expected of the participants, and the authors flag that. Evidence: decent
  • Expect some pull to check in between. Even the batched group worried more about missing notifications than the usual group. Evidence: decent In the email study, people told to check three times a day ended up at about five. Evidence: decent

Watch out

It's one two-week trial, of Android users in India, most of them men. Evidence: decent An app did the batching for them. Nobody has tested people holding themselves to three checks. Evidence: worth trying Even the batched group worried more about missing notifications. Evidence: decent

The email study compared a limited week with a week of checking as often as possible, not with a normal week, though people checked about as often that week as they said they usually did. And they managed about five checks a day, not three. Evidence: decent

If your job needs fast replies, agree the times with the people who depend on you. For the phone itself, see phone in another room.

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.