steady

Happiness · Money, spent right

Book the experience, not the thing

Evidence: decent

Do this

Next time there's spare money: a trip, a match, a course, a meal. Best shared with people. Not the gadget.

How to do it

  1. Book it with people. The social part carried the effect; a solo experience did no better than a thing.
  2. Pick something likely to go well. A bad experience stung more than a bad purchase.
  3. With spare money, not rent money. At the lowest incomes, experiences had no edge.
  4. Keep the tool you use every day. Things gave smaller lifts, more often.

How an experience pays offTap a word for what it means

  1. Adaptationwears the thing down

    People got used to things faster than to experiences. That cuts both ways; a bad trip stays bad longer too.

  2. Retellingpolishes it

    The authors think experiences improve in the memory and the telling, and become part of who you are. That's their explanation, not a test.

  3. Other peopledo most of the work

    In four studies, experiences shared with others beat things. Experiences done alone did no better than things.

  4. Youthe better bet

    With money to spare, the odds favour the shared experience. At the lowest incomes the edge disappeared.

Why it works

Asked about a purchase that made them happier, people pick experiences over things, not quite two to one, and the gap held in the smaller lab studies too. Evidence: decent

You get used to a thing; it just sits there. An experience is over before you can get used to it, it gets better in the retelling, and it usually came with people. Evidence: worth trying That last part does most of the work. Evidence: decent

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 2 min read.

What happens in your brain

This chain is behaviour, not brain areas. Nobody has scanned it.

Adaptation wears the thing down. In a study of how purchases felt over time, people adapted more slowly to experiences than to things. That's why a good experience keeps giving, and also why a bad one keeps hurting. Evidence: decent

The retelling polishes it. The original researchers argue that experiences are more open to a kinder rewrite in memory, become part of who you are, and give you something to talk about with other people. That's their explanation of the result, not something they tested one piece at a time. Evidence: worth trying

Other people do most of the work. Across four studies, when researchers separated "experience or thing" from "shared or alone", the sharing mattered and the experience-versus-thing difference disappeared. A shared experience beat a thing; an experience on your own did no better than a thing. Evidence: decent

You get the better bet. With money to spare, the odds favour the shared experience. Evidence: decent That it works for any one purchase of yours is a guess. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • A national phone survey of 1,263 American adults who handle their household's money: 57% said their experiential purchase made them happier, 34% said the material one. The lead held in almost every group, though men, older people and people in the country leaned less towards experiences. Evidence: decent
  • In the same survey, at the lowest incomes people were as likely to name the thing as the experience. Evidence: decent Later studies found the same: people with fewer resources got no extra happiness from experiences, and sometimes more from things. Evidence: decent
  • 97 students thinking of a recent purchase over $100 rated experiences as bringing more happiness and better value; in a lab study with 70 students, thinking about an experience put people in a better mood than thinking about a thing. Evidence: decent
  • Four studies: shared experiences beat things; solo experiences didn't. Evidence: decent
  • People given 20 Canadian dollars to spend on a thing or an experience, then asked daily for two weeks: things gave smaller lifts more often, experiences bigger lifts less often. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • Next time there's spare money: a trip, a match, a course, a meal. Best shared with people. Not the gadget.
  • Book it with someone. On your own, the edge was gone. Evidence: decent
  • Pick something likely to go well. Evidence: decent
  • Still the safest bet with a spare few hundred. Evidence: worth trying

Watch out

Most of the evidence is what people say, not what they lived. Evidence: decent Experiences that go badly can leave you less happy than a disappointing thing. Evidence: decent If money is tight, a useful thing may do you as much good. Evidence: decent

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.