steady

Happiness · Money, spent right

Spend a little on someone else

Evidence: worth trying

Do this

Once a month, a small amount you'd have spent on yourself goes on someone else. Lunch, a gift, a cause you'd back.

How to do it

  1. Once a month, from money you'd have spent on yourself. Five dollars did as much as twenty in the original.
  2. Do it, don't just remember doing it. Recalling past giving barely moved anyone.
  3. Someone close, if you can. Recalling spending on a close tie lifted mood more than on an acquaintance.
  4. Make it something you'd notice giving up, and your own choice. Chosen giving made reward areas more active than taxed.

In your brainTap a word for what it means

  1. VTAcounts giving as a reward

    In a scan study, choosing to give to real charities made the VTA and the striatum more active, as getting money did.

  2. Choiceadds to it

    Money sent to a food bank like a tax made reward areas more active. Giving it by choice made them more active still.

  3. Striatumtracks the lift

    In 48 people who'd pledged to spend on others or on themselves, striatum activity during generous choices went with how much happier they got.

  4. Youa bit happier, briefly

    Measured the same day. Whether a monthly habit adds up to anything lasting hasn't been tested.

Why it works

The famous study handed people five or twenty dollars and told half to spend it on themselves, half on someone else. The give-away group felt better that evening. It's in every happiness book. Evidence: decent

The honest update: the original had forty-six people, and a careful repeat in 2022 didn't find the effect on the original measure, only on an extra, exploratory question. Evidence: decent A much bigger study of a similar set-up, registered in advance, did find it, smaller than in the original. Evidence: decent Probably true, small, not settled for a habit. Evidence: worth trying

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.

What happens in your brain

These are separate findings, lined up. Nobody has traced the whole chain in one person.

Giving registers as a reward. In a scan study, people decided whether to give to real charities out of money they'd otherwise take home. Choosing to give made the VTA and the striatum more active, the same areas that were more active when they simply got money. Evidence: decent Scans track blood flow, so this shows those areas at work, not a feeling of reward.

Choosing adds to it. In another scan study, women were given a sum of money and some of it went to a local food bank. Taken from them like a tax, it made reward areas more active. Given by choice, more active still. Evidence: decent

The striatum tracks the lift. 50 people were promised 25 Swiss francs a week for four weeks; half pledged to spend it on others, half on themselves; 48 were analysed. In the scanner, the pledgers made more generous choices, and striatum activity during those choices went with how much their happiness rose by the end of the session. Evidence: decent Happiness was measured in the lab that day, not after the four weeks, and most were women. Evidence: decent

A bit happier, briefly. Across the experiments, the lift was measured within hours. Evidence: decent Whether giving once a month adds up to something lasting hasn't been tested. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • 46 people were given $5 or $20 and told to spend it by the end of the day, on themselves or on someone else. That evening, the ones who'd spent on others reported a better mood. How much they'd been given made no difference. Evidence: worth trying
  • 133 students repeated it in 2022 with $10. On the original measure there was no difference; an extra, exploratory question, "how happy were you right after spending it", did show one. Evidence: decent
  • 712 Canadian students in a registered study bought a gift bag, for a sick child or for themselves. The ones who bought for the child reported more good mood right after. The effect was smaller than in the original study, and three in four were women. Evidence: decent
  • Just remembering a time you spent on others did little: no difference in 1,950 adults, and a tiny one in 5,199 when the task was made more engaging. Evidence: decent
  • In survey data from 136 countries, giving to charity went with more happiness, in poor and rich countries alike. Evidence: decent That's a link, not a test.

How to do it

  • Once a month, a small amount you'd have spent on yourself. The amount didn't matter in the original. Evidence: worth trying
  • Lunch, a gift, a cause you'd back. Buying for a sick child worked in the big study; buying for someone close did more than for an acquaintance when people recalled past spending. Evidence: decent
  • Do it, don't just think about past times you did. Evidence: decent
  • Cheap enough to run on yourself. The trick is to make it something you'd notice giving up. Evidence: worth trying

Watch out

The effect is real but small, and it was measured the same day. Evidence: decent Nobody has tested a monthly habit or whether the lift lasts. Evidence: worth trying The scan studies were about money for charity in a lab, not lunch with a friend. Evidence: decent

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.