steady

Stress and nerves · Ahead of it

Write about something else first

10 minEvidence: worth trying

Do this

Well before a review or a conversation you're dreading, while you're still calm, spend ten minutes writing about something you care about that has nothing to do with it. Your kids, your trade, a friend.

How to do it

  1. Pick one thing you care about that has nothing to do with the review. Kids, your trade, a friend, what you believe.
  2. Write for ten minutes about why it matters to you. Writing about why a value matters is the standard version in the studies.
  3. Do it while you're still calm, not in the grip of the dread. In one study, people already in a fearful or angry mood got worse results.
  4. Then go in and listen. The point isn't to feel good. It's to hear the criticism as being about one part of you.

In your brainTap a word for what it means

  1. Prefrontalholds the bigger picture

    While people reflected on values they cared about, self and value areas at the front of the brain, and the striatum, were more active than for everyday things.

  2. Cortisolrises less

    In one lab study, people who had written about their most important value had a smaller stress-hormone rise when a panel judged their speech.

  3. Defencedrops a little

    Across many studies, people who had affirmed a value took threatening health warnings on board a bit more. The effect was small.

  4. Youhear the point

    Nobody has tested this before a review at work or a partner's complaint. That it carries over is a guess.

Why it works

When one part of how you see yourself is under attack, you defend it harder. In studies of what's called self-affirmation, writing about what you value made people a little less defensive about threatening information on something else, mostly health warnings. Evidence: decent The effect is small, and in larger trials it hasn't always shown up. Evidence: decent Nobody has tested it before a review at work or a partner's complaint. Evidence: worth trying

The criticism is about one part of you. It's easier to hear when you've just reminded yourself it's only one part. Evidence: worth trying

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.

What happens in your brain

The bigger picture comes up. In a scan study, sedentary adults reflected on values they cared about while in the scanner. Compared with people who hadn't affirmed, parts of the prefrontal cortex linked to thinking about yourself, and the ventral striatum, linked to reward and value, were more active. Evidence: decent Scans track blood flow, so this shows those areas at work, not what they were doing. Evidence: decent

The stress hormone rises less. In a lab study of 85 people, those who wrote about their most important value before a standard stress test, a speech and mental arithmetic in front of judges, had a smaller cortisol rise than people who wrote about a value that mattered less to them. Evidence: decent

The defences drop a little. In the same group of sedentary adults, those who had affirmed a value showed more activity in a self and value area at the front of the brain while reading health advice, and went on to sit less over the next month. Evidence: decent The authors read this as affirmed people seeing the advice as relevant to them instead of as an attack. That's their interpretation. Evidence: worth trying

You hear the point. Those are three separate findings, not one mapped pathway. Evidence: decent That they add up to hearing a review at work better is a guess. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • A meta-analysis of 144 experimental tests found small but reliable effects: people who affirmed a value first were slightly more accepting of health-risk messages, slightly more intent on changing, and somewhat more likely to change their behaviour. Evidence: decent
  • 85 people wrote about either their most important or a less important value, then did a speech and arithmetic task in front of evaluators. The group that affirmed their top value had lower cortisol responses. Evidence: decent
  • In 45 sedentary adults with both scan and activity-tracker data, those who affirmed before seeing health messages had more activity in a self and value area of the prefrontal cortex during the messages, and cut their sitting time more over the following month. Evidence: decent
  • In two US national samples, 652 and 448 women who drank alcohol were first put in a fearful, angry or neutral mood, then did a standard affirmation, then read a warning linking alcohol to breast cancer. Among those in a negative mood, affirming made their plans to change less specific, not more. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • Pick one thing you care about that has nothing to do with the review: your kids, your trade, a friend, something you believe. Evidence: worth trying
  • Write for ten minutes about why it matters to you. Writing about why a chosen value matters is the standard version in the studies. Evidence: decent
  • Do it while you're still calm, not when the dread has taken over. In the mood study, people already frightened or angry got worse results. Evidence: decent
  • Then go in and listen. The point isn't to feel good. It's to hear the criticism as being about one part of you. Evidence: worth trying

Watch out

The effect is small. Evidence: decent A well-powered repeat of an affirmation study in schools found no effect at all, in the same setting where an earlier trial had found one. Evidence: decent Most of the evidence is about health warnings, not criticism from a boss. Evidence: decent

Across three lab studies, the effect was weaker when people knew, or were told, what the affirmation was for. Evidence: decent You've just read what it's for, so write about the thing you care about, not about the review.

One complication. Other research finds people sometimes prefer feedback that confirms what they already think of themselves, even when what they think is bad. Evidence: decent The two findings pull in different directions. Evidence: decent

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.