How to do it
- Another room, or at least out of reach. In the original study, pocket or bag wasn't clearly better than the desk.
- Switched off isn't enough. In that study, off or on silent made no difference; distance did.
- Alerts off as well. The week with alerts off and the phone away was the one with less inattention.
- Use it for the hard stuff. The only effect that held across studies was on working memory, the part you think with.
How the phone gets inTap a word for what it means
- Phone nearbypulls at you
The original idea is that part of your mind works at not checking it. People didn't report thinking about the phone more, so that part is a theory.
- Working memoryWorking memoryThe small amount of information you can hold and work with in your head at once, usually about four things. Anything more falls off or needs writing down.Read morea little less room
Pooled across studies, a phone nearby went with a small drop in working memory. Attention, self-control and reasoning tests showed no clear effect.
- Alertsbreak in
With alerts on and the phone in reach, 221 people reported more inattention than in a week with alerts off and the phone away.
- Youcheck less, maybe
Out of reach, a check costs standing up. That the distance changes how often you check hasn't been measured.
Why it works
A phone face down on the desk may still cost you a little. In the original experiments, people whose phone sat on the desk did worse on working-memory and reasoning tests than people whose phone was in another room, even with it switched off. Evidence: worth trying That result didn't hold in a larger direct replication. Evidence: decent Pooled across studies, what's left is a small cost to working memory, the part of your mind that holds what you're thinking about. Evidence: decent
Silent mode didn't help in those experiments. Distance did. Evidence: worth trying Putting the phone away also takes the alerts out of the picture, and alerts plus a phone within reach went with more inattention. Evidence: decent
The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.
What happens in your brain
The phone pulls at you. The researchers' idea is that a phone you care about draws some attention even when you're not using it, and part of your mind goes on not checking it. Evidence: worth trying People in the original study didn't report thinking about their phone more when it was on the desk, so this stays a theory. Evidence: decent
Working memory gets a little less room. Pooled across studies, having a phone nearby went with a small drop in working memory. Evidence: decent Tests of sustained attention, self-control and reasoning showed no clear effect when pooled. Evidence: decent The pooled effect was much smaller than in the first studies. Evidence: decent
Alerts break in. For one week, 221 people kept alerts on and the phone within reach or sight; for another week, alerts off and the phone away. They reported more inattention in the alerts-on week. Evidence: decent Both things changed together, so this can't say whether it was the sound or the distance. Evidence: decent
You check less, maybe. Out of reach, a check means standing up. That this cuts how often you check is my guess, not a measured result. Evidence: worth trying
The proof
- 520 students did working-memory and reasoning tests with their phone on the desk, in a pocket or bag, or in another room. Other room beat desk; pocket or bag was in between and not clearly different from either. Evidence: worth trying
- In a second experiment with 275 students, the same pattern showed on working memory, and it made no difference whether the phone was on or off. A test of sustained attention showed no effect. Evidence: worth trying
- A preregistered direct replication of that second experiment, 383 students, found no difference between the desk, the pocket or bag and another room, with the phone on or off. Evidence: decent
- A review pooled 56 effects from 7,093 people. Only one pooled effect was clear: a small drop in working memory. The others, including reasoning, were null. The author flags that many studies were small and differed in method. Evidence: decent
- 221 people spent a week with alerts on and the phone within reach, and a week with alerts off and the phone away. They reported more inattention and hyperactivity with alerts on. Evidence: decent
How to do it
- When you need to think, the phone goes to another room, or at least out of arm's reach. In the original study, a pocket or bag wasn't clearly better than the desk. Evidence: worth trying
- Switching it off didn't help in the study. Distance did. Evidence: worth trying
- Turn the alerts off too. Evidence: decent
- Save it for the hard stuff: planning, writing, anything where you hold several things in mind. That's the only thing the pooled data say it touches. Evidence: decent
Watch out
The brain-drain study got a lot of press. A larger direct replication found nothing, and the pooled data show a small effect on working memory only. Evidence: decent So expect a small edge, not a new brain. Evidence: worth trying It costs nothing, which is why it's still worth doing.
The alerts study changed alerts and distance at the same time, so it can't tell which one mattered. Evidence: decent For the rest of the phone habit, see say what you're looking for and three checks a day.