steady

Focus and work · The phone

Log out every time

Evidence: worth trying

Do this

The app you scroll most: log out when you're done. Opening it then costs a password instead of a tap.

How to do it

  1. Log out of the one app you scroll most, every time you're done. One app, not all of them.
  2. Turn off saved passwords and face unlock for it. If the phone logs you in, the pause is gone.
  3. At the login screen, closing it is a real option. Backing out was what worked best in the pause study.
  4. Or delete the app and use the browser version. Same job, more friction.

How friction buys a pauseTap a word for what it means

  1. Habitthe hand moves first

    Phone checks are brief and repeated, and much of it runs before you've decided anything.

  2. Quick rewardkeeps it going

    In a field experiment, checking took hold when new content was very quick to reach.

  3. Frictionbuys a pause

    In an online test with 500 people, a short wait before opening videos cut how often they watched. An easy way to back out cut it most.

  4. Youchoose, sometimes

    A login screen adds a wait and a way out. That it works like the pop-up in the studies is a guess; nobody has tested logging out.

Why it works

Checking the phone is a habit, not a decision: the hand moves before you've thought about it. Evidence: decent Field studies of real phone use found checks are brief and repeated, and the habit took hold when new content was quick to reach. Evidence: decent

A habit runs on a short path. Make the path longer and the hand often stops halfway. Evidence: decent Logging out adds a wait and a way out. Common advice, sensible mechanism, no trial of this exact trick. Evidence: worth trying

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 2 min read.

What happens in your brain

This chain is behaviour, not brain areas. Nobody has scanned it.

The hand moves first. Actions repeated in the same setting start to run from the setting, with little deciding. That's a habit. Evidence: solid On phones, the typical form is the checking habit: a brief, repeated look at content that changes. Evidence: decent

A quick reward keeps it going. In a controlled field experiment, checking took hold and was reinforced when the new content was very quick to get to. Evidence: decent

Friction buys a pause. In a preregistered online test with 500 people, a short wait before opening social media videos cut how often they watched, and an easy option to back out cut it most. A message asking whether they really wanted to didn't work. Evidence: decent In that test, the moment of "do I actually want this?" wasn't what did it; the wait and the easy exit were. Evidence: decent

You choose, sometimes. A login screen is a wait with an exit. That it works like the pop-up is my guess. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • Several sources of smartphone data, across three studies: checking is brief, repeated inspection of content that updates, it sometimes leads on to other use, and in a controlled field experiment it took hold when the reward was very quick to reach. Evidence: decent
  • 500 people in a preregistered online experiment: a short wait reduced how often they opened videos, the option to back out reduced it most, and a message prompting them to think had no effect. Evidence: decent
  • 280 people who had installed a pop-up app that makes you wait ten seconds before chosen apps: they backed out about a third of the time, and after six weeks they opened those apps 57% less. There was no control group, the users chose the app themselves, people who stopped using it were left out, and one author made it. Evidence: worth trying

How to do it

  • Log out of the one app you scroll most, every time you're done.
  • Turn off saved passwords and face unlock for it. If the phone logs you in, the pause is gone. Evidence: worth trying
  • At the login screen, closing it is a real option. Backing out was what worked best in the pause study. Evidence: decent
  • Deleting the app and using the browser version does the same job with more friction. Evidence: worth trying For more distance, put the phone in another room.

Watch out

Nobody has tested logging out. Evidence: worth trying The closest evidence is a pop-up app studied on its own users, with no control group, co-written by its maker. Evidence: decent Checking can move to another app. Evidence: worth trying

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.