steady

Sleep · Before bed

Phone out of the bedroom

Evidence: worth trying

Do this

Charge it somewhere else. Buy an alarm clock if that's the excuse.

How to do it

  1. Charge it outside the bedroom. If it's in reach, the last scroll decides your bedtime, not you.
  2. Buy a cheap alarm clock. It takes away the reason the phone is by the bed.
  3. Stop the phone half an hour before bed. That's the version that helped in the small trial.
  4. Don't count on night mode. It made no difference to sleep in the trial that tested it.

How the phone delays sleepTap a word for what it means

  1. Body clockpushed a little later

    Four hours of a tablet at full brightness in a near-dark lab delayed the sleep hormone melatonin by 1.5 hours. Ordinary rooms are brighter, so the extra from a screen counts for less.

  2. What's on itkeeps you alert

    Cutting the phone for the last half hour lowered how wound-up students felt at bedtime. Experts agree content hurts teenagers' sleep; for adults they couldn't agree.

  3. Bedtimeslides later

    Young adults lay in bed about 40 minutes before trying to sleep. The longer that gap, the more likely they slept badly.

  4. Youasleep sooner, maybe

    Keeping the phone out of the room has never been tested itself. That it removes the light, the feed and the late scroll at once is my reasoning.

Why it works

Two things about a phone in bed. The light tells your body clock it's still daytime, though the effect of screen light alone is smaller than headlines say. Evidence: decent What's on the screen may be the bigger problem: news, mail and feeds keep you alert, and one more scroll pushes bed back without you deciding it. Evidence: worth trying

Out of the room deals with both, and with the reach for it at 3am. That's my reasoning; nobody has tested the move itself. Evidence: worth trying Night mode made no difference in the one trial that tested it. Evidence: decent

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 4 min read.

What happens in your brain

The light nudges the clock. In the best-known lab study, 12 young adults read for about four hours before bed on a tablet at full brightness, or from a printed book, five evenings each, in a room kept at about 3 lux. With the tablet, their evening melatonin, the hormone that rises before sleep, was about 55% lower, it started rising about an hour and a half later, and they took about 10 minutes longer to fall asleep and felt sleepier the next morning. Evidence: decent A normal lit room at night is far brighter than that lab, so a screen adds less. Evidence: worth trying Glasses that filter blue light have shown mixed effects on sleep, clearest in people with insomnia and a few other conditions. Evidence: decent

What's on it keeps you alert. In a small trial, students who stopped using the phone for the last half hour before bed reported feeling less wound-up at bedtime. Evidence: worth trying An expert panel agreed that what's on the screen before sleep harms children's and teenagers' sleep. For adults it couldn't reach agreement on screens, their light or their content. The panel's view was that adults may be more resilient, or that there isn't yet enough research. Evidence: decent

Bedtime slides. In a survey of 338 people aged 18 to 25, there was an average gap of 39 minutes between getting into bed and trying to sleep. People with a gap of over an hour were about nine times as likely to be poor sleepers as those who went straight to sleep. Evidence: decent It's a survey, so it shows a link, not what caused what. Evidence: decent

You, maybe asleep sooner. Put the three together and a phone in another room takes away the light, the feed and the late scroll at once. That step is my reasoning, not a finding. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • 12 healthy young adults spent two weeks in a lab: five evenings reading about four hours on a tablet, five with a printed book. With the tablet they took about 10 minutes longer to fall asleep (about 26 against 16), had about 55% less evening melatonin, a body clock running about 1.5 hours later, less dream sleep, and were sleepier the next morning. The tablet was at full brightness in a nearly dark room. Evidence: decent
  • 38 students who slept badly and used their phones in bed were split into two groups. One stopped using the phone 30 minutes before bed for four weeks; the phones were locked or the researchers phoned to check. That group reported falling asleep faster (about 31 minutes down to 18 in their diaries), sleeping a little longer and feeling less wound-up. Small, self-reported, and the participants were motivated. Evidence: worth trying
  • 167 people aged 18 to 24 spent a week using their iPhone in the hour before bed with Night Shift on, with it off, or not using the phone at all. Wrist sensors found no difference between the groups overall. Among those who usually slept about seven hours or more, the no-phone group slept best. Evidence: decent
  • 58 adults kept media diaries and slept with a home EEG. Media in the hour before sleep went with earlier bedtimes, and didn't change the share of deep or dream sleep. Longer sessions went with later bedtimes and less sleep. Evidence: decent
  • An expert panel reviewing 35 experiments and trials found screens before bed harm young people's sleep, and couldn't agree on adults. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • Charge it outside the bedroom. Evidence: worth trying
  • Buy a cheap alarm clock, if the alarm is the excuse.
  • Stop using it half an hour before bed. That's what the small trial used. Evidence: worth trying
  • Don't count on night mode. In the trial it made no difference to sleep. Evidence: decent
  • For the rest of the phone habit, see phone in another room and no news first or last.

Watch out

The famous light result came from four hours of a tablet at full brightness in a dark lab. Real-life studies find smaller or no effects in adults. Evidence: decent The best evidence that screens hurt sleep is in children and teenagers. Evidence: decent The one trial that showed a benefit was small and relied on diaries; a larger one found no overall difference. Evidence: decent Keeping the phone out of the room hasn't been tested on its own. Evidence: worth trying It costs nothing, which is why it's still here.

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.