steady

Sleep · Before bed

No news first or last

Evidence: worth trying

Do this

No news or feeds in the first thirty minutes of the day or the last thirty before bed.

How to do it

  1. Nothing from the news or feeds for the first thirty minutes. Water, light, then the phone.
  2. Nothing for the last thirty before bed. That it helps you wind down is a guess, but a cheap one.
  3. Charge the phone outside the bedroom. It does most of this for you.
  4. Get the news once, mid-day, from one source you chose. That's my suggestion, not a finding.

How the news follows you

  1. Bad newsstirs the body

    Across 17 countries, negative news stories set off more sweat on the skin and heart-rate change than positive ones, on average. Not in everyone.

  2. Moodtilts darker

    In a lab, 14 minutes of negative TV news raised anxiety and sadness and made people's own worries look bigger.

  3. Bedtimeharder to wind down

    Students who stopped using the phone half an hour before bed felt less wound-up. News at bedtime itself hasn't been tested, so this step is a guess.

  4. Youfirst and last word

    Whether thirty news-free minutes at each end changes your day or your sleep has never been tested. It's a rule of thumb.

Why it works

Bad news stirs the body more than good news, on average across the 17 countries where it's been measured, though not in every country or every person. Evidence: decent A feed built to hold attention has every reason to use that. Evidence: worth trying In the studies that have looked, news people see as negative goes with worse mood at the time; which causes which isn't settled. Evidence: decent

First thing, you're handing your morning to whatever is worst in the world. Last thing, you're taking it to bed. The thirty-minute rule is a rule of thumb, not a trial. Evidence: worth trying

Phone charging outside the bedroom does most of this for you.

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.

What happens in your brain

Bad news stirs the body. 1,156 people in 17 countries on six continents watched seven real BBC news stories while sensors tracked sweat on their skin and their heart rhythm. On average, the more negative the story, the stronger the response. Country by country the pattern was weaker and didn't always reach significance, and individuals varied a lot. Evidence: decent These are body measures of arousal and attention, not brain scans. Evidence: decent

Mood tilts darker. In a lab study, people shown a 14-minute news bulletin edited to be negative became more anxious and sad than people shown neutral or positive news, and they blew up a personal worry of their own more. Evidence: decent In a diary study, news people saw as negative went with worse mood at the time. Evidence: decent

Bedtime gets harder to wind down, maybe. In a small trial, students who stopped using the phone for the last half hour before bed reported feeling less wound-up at bedtime and falling asleep faster. Evidence: worth trying That news last thing keeps you up specifically hasn't been tested. In one home study of 58 adults, media in the hour before sleep didn't change how much deep or dream sleep they got. Evidence: decent

You get the first and last word. Putting these together into a thirty-minute rule at each end of the day is my guess, not a finding. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • 1,156 people in 17 countries watched real news clips while sensors tracked skin sweat and heart rhythm. Negative stories got stronger reactions on average, with a lot of variation between people. Evidence: decent
  • Three groups watched 14-minute TV news bulletins edited to be positive, neutral or negative. The negative group ended up more anxious and sad, and catastrophised a personal worry more. Evidence: decent
  • 63 people reported their news exposure and mood five times a day for 10 days. News they saw as negative went with more negative and less positive mood, more so when it felt personally relevant. Evidence: decent
  • 61 young adults, mostly women and two-thirds chosen for difficult childhoods, kept daily diaries for 30 days during the pandemic. Days they got coronavirus news through social media went with more depression and trauma symptoms; days with TV, radio or papers didn't. The authors think the link runs both ways. Evidence: decent
  • Nobody has tested a news-free first and last half hour. Evidence: worth trying

How to do it

  • No news or feeds for the first thirty minutes. Water, light, a window, then the phone. Evidence: worth trying On waking, blood flow in the front of the brain kept rising for about 15 minutes, and full alertness took 20 to 30. Evidence: decent
  • None in the last thirty before bed. Evidence: worth trying
  • Charge the phone outside the bedroom: phone out of the bedroom.
  • If you want the news, get it once, in the middle of the day, from a source you picked. That's my habit suggestion, not a finding. Evidence: worth trying

Watch out

The thirty-minute rule is common sense, not a studied intervention. Evidence: worth trying The news studies used TV bulletins and mood diaries, not a phone feed in bed, and the diary links can run both ways. Evidence: decent If something in the news directly affects you, read it. This is about the feed, not about hiding.

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.