steady

Focus and work · Making it stick

Picture it, then picture the obstacle

3 minEvidence: decent

Do this

Imagine the goal done, for a minute. Then name the one thing most likely to stop you. Then: "If that happens, I will…"

How to do it

  1. Picture the goal done, for about a minute. Make it concrete. That's the part everyone already does.
  2. Then name the one thing most likely to stop you. The obstacle is what turns a daydream into a job.
  3. Then the plan: "If that happens, I will…" The 21-study review tested the version with this line.
  4. If you honestly don't expect to manage it, you may drop the goal. That's the method working, not failing.

How the obstacle helpsTap a word for what it means

  1. Fantasyfeels like arriving

    Picturing the goal already reached left people feeling less energetic, and where it was measured, nudged blood pressure down a little. The researchers read that as the body standing down.

  2. Obstaclebrings back the gap

    Setting the real obstacle against the wish raised energy and commitment in people who expected to succeed. People who didn't expect to tended to let the goal go.

  3. Prefrontalworks the problem

    In a brain recording study, contrasting went with more activity in the front and sides of the brain than resting; daydreaming about the goal didn't. The researchers read that as planning and memory at work.

  4. Youfollow through, a bit more

    Across 21 studies, contrast plus an if-then plan raised goal success by a small-to-medium amount, probably less once unpublished studies are allowed for.

Why it works

Vision boards and "see it as already yours" are everywhere, including in neuroscience podcasts. The catch: in controlled studies, people who imagined the goal already achieved felt less energetic afterwards, and where blood pressure was measured, it dipped slightly. Evidence: decent The researchers' reading is that the body eases off as if the job were done. Evidence: worth trying

What works better is the contrast. Picture the win, then the real obstacle, then the plan for the obstacle. Across 21 studies, that full version raised goal success by a small-to-medium amount. Evidence: decent Pair it with the if-then plan. That's the whole method.

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.

What happens in your brain

The fantasy feels like arriving. In three experiments, people told to picture a wished-for future going perfectly ended up with less energy than people who questioned it, pictured it going badly, or thought about something neutral. Evidence: decent In the first, 164 women students pictured themselves in a pair of shoes they wanted; their blood pressure dipped about two points, while it didn't move in the group that questioned the fantasy. The effect was small. Evidence: decent The idea that the body stands down because the goal feels reached is their interpretation. Evidence: worth trying

The obstacle brings back the gap. Setting the obstacle against the wish, called mental contrasting, raised energy, measured by blood pressure and by how people felt, and that energy went with stronger commitment. That held for people who expected to succeed. Evidence: decent People with low expectations tended to commit less, which is the point: it sorts goals you can reach from ones you can't. Evidence: decent

The prefrontal cortex works the problem. In a study that recorded brain activity with MEG, contrasting went with more activity than resting in prefrontal, frontal, parietal and temporal areas, and in the visual areas at the back. Indulging in the fantasy didn't show that. Evidence: decent The researchers read it as planning, working memory and memory of past attempts at work. That reading is theirs; the recording shows activity, not what it's for. Evidence: worth trying

You follow through a bit more. Across 21 studies and nearly 16,000 people, contrast plus an if-then plan raised goal success. Evidence: decent Whether each step of this chain causes the next hasn't been tested as one pathway. They're separate findings. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • 164 women students pictured themselves in shoes they wanted. Their blood pressure dipped about two points; in the group that questioned the fantasy, it didn't change. Evidence: decent
  • 40 students pictured an ideal coming week. Right after, they felt less energetic than students who wrote neutrally about the week, and a week later they reported getting less done. Evidence: decent
  • Two studies: mental contrasting raised energy, measured by the body and by self-report, and that energy went with commitment, in people who expected to succeed. Evidence: decent
  • A review of 21 studies with 15,907 people found contrast plus an if-then plan lifted goal success with a small-to-medium effect. There were signs of publication bias; corrected, the effect was smaller but still there. Face-to-face versions did better than written ones. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • Picture the goal done, for about a minute. Make it concrete.
  • Then name the one thing most likely to stop you. Evidence: worth trying
  • Then the plan: "If that happens, I will…" That's the version the 21-study review tested. Evidence: decent
  • If you honestly don't expect to manage it, you may find you drop the goal. That's the method doing its job. Evidence: decent

Watch out

The fantasy studies measured energy and people's own account of what they got done, mostly in American students. Nobody measured effort directly. Evidence: decent The blood pressure drop was small. Evidence: decent

The 21-study effect is small to medium and may be smaller than it looks, because of publication bias. Evidence: decent It helps you commit to goals you can reach and let go of the rest. It won't make an unrealistic goal happen. Evidence: decent

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.