steady

Mood · In your head

Test the want, not the like

Evidence: worth trying

Do this

When you can't be bothered to go, go anyway. Decide whether you like it once you're there, not from the sofa.

How to do it

  1. Go before you decide. The can't-be-bothered feeling is a price, not a forecast.
  2. Judge it once you've started. That's when the liking side has something to read.
  3. Shrink the start if the price is too high. A smaller first step costs less to buy.
  4. Keep an honest score. If it still feels like nothing, time after time, that's worth taking to a doctor.

In your brainTap a word for what it means

  1. Dopamineprices the effort

    It sets how much a reward seems worth working for. In animals, with less of it they took the small easy reward over the bigger one that took work.

  2. Striatumdrives the wanting

    Where dopamine turns "that would be good" into getting up. Rats with almost none left here stopped going for food but still liked sugar.

  3. Likingruns separately

    In animals, enjoyment didn't need that dopamine. People with depression rated sweet tastes as nice as anyone else did.

  4. Youcheck on arrival

    From the sofa you mostly read the wanting side, and the price. Whether you enjoy it you can only read once you're there. That step is a guess.

Why it works

Wanting something and enjoying it are separate processes in the brain. Dopamine drives the wanting, the pull to get up and go. Enjoying the thing once you're there is a different process. Evidence: decent In depression, the wanting side may take the bigger hit. Evidence: worth trying

So "I don't feel like it" may be a reading from the wanting side alone. It tells you the start looks expensive, the effort cost. It tells you much less about whether you'd enjoy it. Evidence: worth trying

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.

What happens in your brain

Dopamine prices the effort. In animal work, blocking dopamine or damaging its supply made animals stop working for a bigger reward and take the small easy one instead. Evidence: decent

The striatum turns wanting into moving. The striatum is where much of that dopamine lands. In rats with up to 99% of the dopamine gone from the striatum, the animals stopped eating on their own, yet their faces still showed normal liking when sugar was put in their mouths. Evidence: decent The researchers' conclusion: dopamine is needed for wanting a reward, not for liking it. Evidence: decent

Liking runs on its own. In four separate studies using a sweet-taste test, people with depression rated the taste as pleasant as people without depression did. Evidence: decent In a small study of 20 people with depression and 15 without, the depressed group chose the harder, better-paid option less often. Evidence: decent Put together, the review behind this hack argues that doctors' "loss of interest or pleasure" lumps wanting and enjoying together, and that studies had tested enjoying far more than wanting. Splitting the two is the authors' proposal, not a settled fact. Evidence: worth trying

You read the price, not the pleasure. So the reading from the sofa leans on the wanting side. Evidence: worth trying People are also bad at guessing how things will feel. In two experiments, people underestimated how much happier a walk outside would make them than one indoors. Evidence: decent That's the reason to decide on arrival. The link from the rat work to your evening is an inference. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • Rats with up to 99% of the dopamine in the striatum destroyed showed normal liking reactions to sugar and normal dislike of a bitter taste. They had stopped eating by themselves. Evidence: decent
  • 20 people with depression and 15 without played a game choosing between an easy task for a dollar and a hard task of fast button presses for more money. The depressed group chose the hard, better-paid task less often, and more so the longer the current episode had lasted. Most of them were on antidepressants, and the sample was small. Evidence: decent
  • Across four studies with a sweet-taste test, people with depression and matched controls reported no difference in how pleasant it was. Evidence: decent
  • 26 randomised trials, 1,524 people: behavioural activation, a therapy built on doing planned activities without waiting to feel like it, cut depression symptoms more than control conditions. Most trials were of low quality and follow-up was short. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • Go before you decide. The can't-be-bothered feeling is the price of starting, not a forecast of the evening. Evidence: worth trying
  • Judge it once you've started, not from the door. Guesses can miss: in the walking experiments they missed low. Evidence: decent
  • If the price is too high, shrink the start. Five minutes of the walk, one set at the gym. Evidence: worth trying
  • Keep an honest score over a few tries, not one.

Watch out

That idea comes from a review of brain research, not from a trial of this habit. Treat it as a test you run, not a promise. The wanting-versus-liking split is well shown in rats; in people with depression, which side takes the bigger hit is still argued over. Evidence: decent

Not every "can't be bothered" is wrong. Sometimes you're tired and the right move is rest. Evidence: worth trying

If you go, and go again, and it still feels like nothing, that's information too. Take it to a doctor: two questions.

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.