How to do it
- Write down three things you can do that nobody around you does. A boiler, a contract. That's what you have to offer.
- One person, by name. "Help young people" never gets a date in the diary; a name does.
- An hour a month, booked. The trial volunteers had a fixed commitment, not an open offer.
- Ask what they're stuck on. Answer that, not the lecture you'd like to give.
What mentoring gives youTap a word for what it means
- GenerativityGenerativityA psychology term for caring about the next generation and acting on it: raising, teaching, mentoring, building things that outlast you. Erik Erikson named it the main task of midlife.Read morewants to pass it on
Caring about what you leave to the people after you. People who score higher on it also report doing more of it, like teaching someone a skill.
- Mentoringgives it an outlet
In a trial, older adults randomly placed as mentors in schools felt more generative than controls at every check over two years. Most were women.
- Feeling usefultracks with health
In adults in their seventies, the few who rarely felt useful to others were more likely to become disabled or die over seven years. A link, not a cause.
- Youconnected, worthwhile
People who put more into the next generation felt more connected and more worthwhile. Mentoring one person as a fix for a role that ended is untested.
Why it works
Psychologists have a word for caring about what you leave to the people after you: generativity. People who put more into the next generation feel more connected and more worthwhile. Evidence: decent That's a correlation. Men who are doing well may simply have more to give.
A long US study of 2,252 adults, surveyed about ten years apart, found the other side of it: people who later felt they'd given less than they expected to were less satisfied with life. Evidence: decent That's a correlation too. Feeling low could make you feel you've fallen short, not only the other way round.
Nobody has tested mentoring one person as a fix for a role that ended. It's the most direct way I know to act on the finding. Evidence: worth trying What you knew didn't retire with you.
The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 2 min read.
What happens in your brain
This chain is behaviour, not brain areas. Nobody has scanned it.
You want to pass it on. Researchers built a scale to measure generativity in 1992, and people who score higher on it also report doing more of it, like teaching someone a skill. Evidence: decent
Mentoring gives it an outlet. In a trial in Baltimore, 702 adults over sixty were randomly placed either as helpers in primary schools, about fifteen hours a week, or offered the usual volunteering. The school group felt more generative at every check over two years, and more so the more they took part. The effect was small, and 85% were women. Evidence: decent
Feeling useful tracks with health. In 1,189 Americans in their seventies, picked as fitter than most of their age group, the few who rarely or never felt useful to family and friends, about 6%, were more likely to become disabled or die over the next seven years, even after the researchers took other differences into account. Evidence: decent That's a link. Being ill can also make you feel less useful.
You feel more connected. In a large US study of adults, people who put more into the next generation felt more connected and more worthwhile. Evidence: decent
The proof
- 702 older adults in the Baltimore trial: school mentors felt more generative than the comparison group at four, twelve and twenty-four months. Small effects, mostly women. Evidence: decent
- 2,252 US adults followed for about ten years: those who gave more to the next generation felt more connected, more worthwhile and in a better mood. Evidence: decent
- 1,189 people aged 70 to 79: rarely feeling useful to others went with more disability and more deaths over seven years. Evidence: decent
- In the same ten-year US study, falling short of what people had expected to give went with lower life satisfaction, and with less connection, self-worth and good mood. The link was clearest up to about 75. Evidence: decent
How to do it
- Not sure what you'd offer? Write down three things you know how to do that nobody around you does. Fixing a boiler, reading a contract, getting a nervous team through a bad week. It counts. That the list helps is my reading, not a tested method. Evidence: worth trying
- Pick one person by name. "Help young people" never gets a date in the diary. "Ask Nikolai how the new job is going" does.
- Offer an hour a month, and book the first one.
- Ask what they're stuck on.
Watch out
Most of the evidence is correlation, and the one trial was mostly women doing fifteen hours a week in schools. Evidence: decent An hour a month with one person is much less than that and hasn't been tested. Evidence: worth trying
If the months since a role ended have brought weeks of low mood, or you've lost interest in almost everything, that's a doctor conversation, not a mentoring one.