How to do it
- Discount the replay on the way home. Your own slips loom larger to you than to them.
- Assume it went better than it felt. On average, the other person liked you more than you guessed.
- Suggest the next thing before you leave, a place and a day, or message it after. A plan is easier to say yes to than "we should hang out"; that part is my guess.
- Shy? Expect a bigger gap. Shyer people underestimated more.
Why the replay misleadsTap a word for what it means
- Replaydwells on your slips
After a first chat, people's thoughts about how the other person saw them were more negative than their thoughts about the other person. The more negative, the bigger the gap.
- Signalsget missed
Outsiders watching videos of the chats could tell how much each person liked the other. The people in the chat didn't pick it up.
- Liking gapLiking gapA bias found in conversation studies: after talking with someone new, people tend to think the other person liked them less than they actually did.Read morelasts for months
New university suite mates underestimated how much they were liked from September through February. By May it had gone.
- Youwait, by default
People also expect a catch-up message to be less welcome than it is. Both mistakes point to doing nothing. That this is why follow-ups stall is a guess.
Why it works
After talking with someone new, people underestimate how much the other person liked them. It showed up with strangers in a lab and with first-year students sharing a university suite. At a workshop, people likewise underrated how interesting they seemed. The researchers call it the liking gap. Evidence: decent I won't give you a size for it. The direction is the useful part.
So the replay on the way home, the joke that fell flat, the pause that went on too long, is a poor guide to how it went. Evidence: decent
The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.
What happens in your brain
This chain is behaviour, not brain areas. Nobody has scanned it.
The replay dwells on your slips. After a five-minute chat with a stranger, people's most salient thoughts about how the other person saw them were more negative than their thoughts about how they saw the other person, and the more negative those thoughts, the bigger the gap. Evidence: decent That was 84 students and recent graduates at one university. Evidence: decent
The signals get missed. Two coders watched videos of first conversations. They could tell how much each person liked the other, but the people in the conversation didn't use those signals when guessing how much they were liked. Evidence: decent Only 15 videos. Evidence: decent
It lasts. 102 first-year students were surveyed about their new suite mates five times over the year. They underestimated how much they were liked in September, October, December and February. By the last survey in May the gap had gone. Evidence: decent The authors suggest that by then they knew each other well, or were deciding whether to live together again. Evidence: worth trying
You wait, by default. It stacks with a second mistake, found in people getting in touch with someone: they expect the message to be less welcome than it turns out to be. Evidence: decent Both mistakes point the same way, towards doing nothing. Evidence: worth trying Send it anyway.
The proof
- Five studies. Strangers in a lab after five minutes of chat, pairs who talked as long as they liked, UK workshop-goers, and new suite mates over a year. In each, people underrated how they came across: how much they were liked or enjoyed, or at the workshop, how interesting they were found. Evidence: decent
- The gap held after conversations from 2 to 45 minutes long. Evidence: decent
- 102 new suite mates, five surveys over an academic year: the gap was there at every survey through February and gone by the one in May. Evidence: decent
- In the first, small study, shyer people had a bigger gap. Self-esteem and sensitivity to rejection made no difference. Evidence: worth trying
- Across 13 preregistered studies, people reaching out underestimated how much it was appreciated. Evidence: decent
How to do it
- Discount the replay on the way home. Evidence: decent
- Assume it went better than it felt. Evidence: decent
- Suggest the next thing before you leave, a place and a day, or message them after. That a plan works better than "we should hang out" is my guess. Evidence: worth trying
- Keep suggesting until they start doing it too. In a study of recent movers and first-year students, more hours together went with closer friendships, and it took dozens of hours to go from acquaintance to casual friend. Evidence: decent
- Shy? Expect a bigger gap than most. Evidence: worth trying
Watch out
The studies measured what people thought after talking, not what happened when they followed up. Evidence: decent Suggesting a plan, before you leave or by message, hasn't been tested. Evidence: worth trying The hours study had people estimate their own hours after the fact. Evidence: decent If after several goes they never suggest one back, that's an answer too. Evidence: worth trying Most people were young, many of them students. At the workshops the measure was how interesting people found each other, not how much they liked each other. Evidence: decent The gap is an average, so some people really didn't click. Evidence: decent