steady

Memory and learning · Keeping the brain plastic

Take a different route

Evidence: worth trying

Do this

Once a week, drive or walk somewhere familiar a way you've never gone. GPS off.

How to do it

  1. Once a week, a new way to somewhere you know. Familiar ends, unfamiliar middle.
  2. GPS off. Following directions is when the hippocampus stopped tracking the streets.
  3. Look at the map before you set off, then put it away. Work the rest out as you go.
  4. On foot counts, and it's easier. So does a new walk with the dog.

In your brainTap a word for what it means

  1. Hippocampusmaps the streets

    When people picked their own way through a filmed London, it tracked how the streets connect. When told which way to go, it didn't.

  2. Prefrontalplans the detour

    At a forced detour, the sides of the front of the brain were more active the more future paths there were to weigh.

  3. Grey mattergrows with years of it

    A separate study. Trainee taxi drivers who learned London grew the back of the hippocampus. Those who failed or quit didn't.

  4. Youkeep your bearings

    Drivers who used GPS more lost more spatial memory, in a small study. That one new route a week prevents this is a guess.

Why it works

Finding your own way uses the hippocampus, the brain's map-maker and memory centre. Evidence: solid Being told which way to go seems to leave it out. In a scan study, it stopped tracking the street layout when people were told which way to turn. Evidence: decent That satnav does the same on a real road is a fair guess, not tested. Evidence: worth trying In one study, people who used satnav more had worse spatial memory over time. Evidence: worth trying

The familiar way wins by default: given a free choice, people drift to the option that asks less of the brain, even when they haven't noticed the difference. Evidence: decent A new route is also a small dose of novelty, which the brain responds to on its own. Evidence: decent Same for a new café, a new lift in the gym, a new walk with the dog, a recipe from scratch, sums without the calculator. Evidence: worth trying

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.

What happens in your brain

The hippocampus maps where you are. In a study of 24 people who learned part of central London and then navigated it on film in a scanner, the back of the right hippocampus tracked how the number of connecting streets changed with each new street they entered. When they were told which button to press instead of choosing, that response wasn't there. Evidence: decent

The front of the brain plans the detour. When the film forced a detour, activity at the sides of the prefrontal cortex rose with how many future paths there were to weigh. Evidence: decent

Used hard for years, the hippocampus grows. London taxi drivers had a bigger back part of the hippocampus than other men, and a smaller front part. Evidence: decent Trainees scanned before and three to four years after learning the city showed the growth only if they qualified. Evidence: decent Compared with bus drivers on fixed routes, taxi drivers had more grey matter at the back of the hippocampus, which points at the navigating, not the driving or the stress. Evidence: decent

Something new gets noticed. In scans, the midbrain area that holds the cells that make dopamine was more active for things that were genuinely new than for familiar ones. Evidence: decent That a new route is enough novelty to matter is an inference. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • 79 trainee taxi drivers were scanned while learning London's roughly 25,000 streets and again three to four years later, alongside 31 controls. The 39 who qualified had more grey matter at the back of both hippocampi. Those who failed or quit, and the controls, showed no change. Evidence: decent
  • 16 male London taxi drivers had a larger back of the hippocampus than 50 men who didn't drive taxis. The longer they'd driven, the bigger it was. Evidence: decent
  • 24 people learned an area of Soho, then navigated a film of it in a scanner. The hippocampus tracked the street network when they navigated, and not when they were told which way to press. Evidence: decent
  • 50 regular drivers: those with more lifetime GPS use had worse spatial memory when they had to find their own way. 13 were retested three years later, and more GPS use in between went with a steeper decline. People who used GPS more didn't say they had a worse sense of direction, which argues against the reverse explanation. The follow-up group is small. Evidence: worth trying

How to do it

  • Once a week, a new way to somewhere you know. Evidence: worth trying
  • GPS off. In the scan study, the hippocampus stopped tracking the streets when people were told which way to go. Evidence: decent
  • Look at the map before you set off, then put it away.
  • On foot counts. A new walk also gets you walking, which has its own evidence. Evidence: decent

Watch out

The taxi drivers spent three to four years learning the city, around 35 hours a week on average for the ones who qualified. One new route a week is nowhere near that, and nobody has tested it. Evidence: decent The GPS study is small and correlational, so it can't show GPS caused the decline, though the authors argue that's the likely direction. Evidence: worth trying The cabbies paid a price too: those who qualified scored worse than controls at recalling a complex drawing half an hour later. Evidence: decent If you're driving, plan the route before you set off. Don't read a map at the wheel.

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.