steady

Energy · Through the day

Swap the task, don't push through

Evidence: worth trying

Do this

When the hard thinking stops moving late in the day, switch to easy work. Big decisions wait until you're fresh.

How to do it

  1. When hard thinking stops moving late in the day, switch. Email, filing, calls that need no thought.
  2. Anything that needs judgement waits until you're fresh. Tired, the hard-work group leaned to the quick, easy option.
  3. Don't ration yourself in the morning. This is about the end of a long, hard stretch, not a tank you drain.

In your brainTap a word for what it means

  1. Prefrontaldoes the hard control

    Tasks that make you override habits lean on the side of the front of the brain. That's the area the study measured.

  2. Glutamatehigher than after easy work

    By the end of the day the hard-work group had more of this signalling chemical there than the easy group. There was no scan before the tasks began to compare with.

  3. Effort costgoes up, maybe

    The researchers' idea is that the build-up makes using that area feel costlier, so easy options win. That link is their interpretation, not something measured.

  4. Youpick easy and now

    The hard-work group chose smaller, sooner, lower-effort options more often. That switching tasks protects your decisions was never tested.

Why it works

In one study, about forty people spent a working day on either hard or easy mental tasks. By the end, the hard-work group had more glutamate, a chemical brain cells use to signal each other, in the prefrontal cortex, the front of the brain that plans and weighs options. They also chose less effort and quicker rewards more often. Evidence: worth trying

The takeaway is mine, and nobody has tested it: when hard work stops moving, grinding on gets you worse work and worse choices. Switch to email, filing, calls that need no thought. Anything that needs judgement waits. Evidence: worth trying

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.

What happens in your brain

The front of the brain does the hard control. The hard tasks made people override automatic responses over and over. That kind of control leans on the lateral prefrontal cortex, the side of the front of the brain, which is where the study measured. Evidence: decent

Glutamate is higher at the end of a hard day. Using a scanner that reads brain chemicals, the researchers found more glutamate there by the end of the day in the hard-work group than in the easy-work group, and no difference in a control area at the back of the brain. Evidence: worth trying A critic reading their figures put the gap at about 10%, and pointed out there was no scan before the tasks began: the gap came mostly from glutamate falling in the easy group, not rising in the hard one. Evidence: worth trying

Effort may start to cost more. The researchers' model is that glutamate building up makes using that area more costly, so the brain steers you toward options that need less control. That's their interpretation, and it's the part the critic questioned. See effort cost. Evidence: worth trying

Your choices tilt to easy and now. Only the hard-work group showed it: their pupils widened less when deciding, and they picked options with less effort and a shorter wait more often. Evidence: worth trying

That's one study, one day, lab tasks, and other researchers have questioned how it was measured. Evidence: decent The mechanism is interesting, not settled. It's also not the old willpower tank, which failed its big tests. The idea here is narrower: a build-up in one part of the brain, not a reserve you ration. Evidence: worth trying

The proof

  • Two groups of volunteers did either high-demand or low-demand tasks across a lab day of about six hours, with money choices in between. Only the high-demand group shifted toward smaller-sooner and lower-effort options, and their pupils widened less as they chose. Evidence: worth trying
  • At the end of the day the high-demand group had higher glutamate in the lateral prefrontal cortex than the low-demand group, about 10% by one critic's reading of the figures. There was no difference in the visual area used as a control. Evidence: worth trying
  • That critic noted there was no baseline scan before the tasks, and that the difference came mostly from a fall in glutamate in the easy group. Other explanations fit the data too. Evidence: worth trying
  • The old idea that self-control drains like a tank was retested in 23 labs with 2,141 people. The effect was close to zero. Evidence: solid

How to do it

  • When the hard thinking stops moving late in the day, switch to easy work. Evidence: worth trying
  • Big decisions wait until you're fresh. Evidence: worth trying
  • Don't ration yourself early in the day. Evidence: decent

Watch out

One study, one day, lab tasks, and a published critique of how glutamate was measured. Evidence: worth trying Nobody has tested whether switching tasks protects your work or your decisions. That part is my reading. Evidence: worth trying

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.