How to do it
- Write three down, in your phone notes. Things that have shifted a flat mood before. Only have one? Try a walk, a call to a friend or a hard session this week, and keep what works.
- When you're flat, take the one you used longest ago. Repeating the same act was what wore off in the experiment.
- Vary how you do each one too. A different route, a different friend to call.
- When one stops working, it isn't broken. You've probably leaned on it too often.
How a lift wears offTap a word for what it means
- AdaptationAdaptationThe tendency to get used to a change in your life, also called the hedonic treadmill: over time a good change stops lifting you and a bad one stops hurting as much.Read moredulls the repeat
The same good thing, done the same way, gives less each time. It's why the raise stopped feeling like a raise.
- Varietykeeps it fresh
In 481 students, the more a good change kept bringing new and surprising experiences, the more good feeling it still gave.
- Moodcounts for more
In the same study, good feelings from a varied change did more for overall happiness weeks later.
- Youhold the lift
Told to vary their kind acts, students held level; told to repeat the same ones, they slid. That this applies to walks and calls is an inference.
Why it works
The brain gets used to things. Hedonic adaptation is the technical name, and it's why the raise stopped feeling like a raise. Evidence: decent The same thing happens to whatever you use to shift a flat mood: the run, the pub, the box set. Used the same way every time, it fades. Evidence: worth trying
Practical version: three lifts, not one, written down so you don't have to think of them on a flat day. Rotate. When one stops working, it isn't broken. You've probably leaned on it too often. Evidence: worth trying
The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 2 min read.
What happens in your brain
The repeat wears off. You adapt to things that stay the same. A good change brings good feelings at first, and they fade as it becomes normal. Evidence: decent That's measured in feelings and ratings, not in brain scans.
Variety keeps it fresh. In a three-month study of 481 students, the more a good change in their lives kept bringing new, surprising experiences, the more good feeling they were still getting from it. Evidence: decent
Good feelings count for more. In the same study, good feelings that came from a varied change did more for how happy people rated themselves weeks later. Evidence: decent It was a survey over time, not an experiment.
You hold the lift. The experiment below found the same when variety was assigned, not just reported. Evidence: decent The wider theory behind it, that what you do on purpose is the lever that lasts, is a synthesis of other work, not a trial in itself. Evidence: decent
The proof
- In a ten-week experiment, 52 students did small kind acts each week. One group was told to vary them; the other repeated the same acts. The varied group held level; the repeat group ended below where it started. Evidence: decent The authors note that students tend to get less happy as a term goes on, so holding level may itself be the gain. Evidence: worth trying One study, reported in a book chapter, measured at the end and not much after, so the number is soft.
- A separate three-month study of 481 students found the same without an experiment: the more variety a good change kept bringing, the more good feeling it gave, and the more that feeling counted towards overall happiness. Evidence: decent
- In a two-week study, 79 students who had made a good change and rated it as more varied held on to more of the boost. It was a self-rating, not an experiment. Evidence: decent
How to do it
- Write three down, in your phone notes: things that have shifted a flat mood before. If you've only got one, try a walk, a call to a friend or a hard session this week, and keep what works. Evidence: worth trying
- When you're flat, take the one you used longest ago. In the experiment, repeating the same act was what wore off. Evidence: decent
- Vary how you do each one too. In one study, the example given was walking a different route to work each day. Evidence: worth trying
- When one stops working, it isn't broken. You've probably leaned on it too often. Evidence: worth trying
Watch out
The direction fits everything else known about adaptation. Evidence: decent But the experiment was small, with students, and tested kind acts, not walks, calls or training. That it carries over to what you use to lift a flat mood is an inference. Evidence: worth trying