How to do it
- One skill, new to you and hard enough to stay hard. Photography with its software gained most; quilting, once the hands knew it, gained less.
- Several hours a week, for months. The study used about 15 hours a week for 14 weeks.
- Learn it with a teacher and assignments. The groups had five hours of teaching and ten of homework a week.
- Judge after three months, not three weeks. The payoff comes after the part where you're bad at it.
In your brain
- New skillkeeps you at the limit
Photography meant a camera and editing software from scratch, with lots of instructions to hold on to between sessions.
- Brain effortscales to the task
In a scanned subgroup, the hard-skill learners' brains eased off on the easy version of a task, so the step up to the hard version was bigger. The authors call it efficiency.
- Youremember more
Memory scores rose more in the hard-skill groups. In the scans, the brain change went with thinking gains, a correlation in a small group.
Why it works
The best test of "do hard new things" put adults aged sixty to ninety into groups for three months. Some learned digital photography or quilting from scratch, about fifteen hours a week. Others joined a social club, or did easy familiar things at home like word puzzles and classical music. Only the groups learning a demanding new skill improved their memory more than the rest: clearly for photography, and not clearly for quilting on its own. Evidence: decent Whether it lasts is less clear; a scan a year on found some of the brain changes still there. Evidence: worth trying
Hard and new is the combination. Social alone didn't do it. Familiar alone didn't do it. Evidence: decent Dabbling in five things gives you the hard part of each without the payoff, because the payoff comes after the part where you're bad at it. Evidence: worth trying
The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.
What happens in your brain
The new skill keeps you at your limit. Photography meant learning a camera and complex editing software, with a lot of instructions to remember between sessions. Quilting leaned more on the hands once the basics were learned. The authors think that's why photography helped memory more. Evidence: decent That explanation is theirs, not tested. Evidence: worth trying
The brain gets more efficient. 39 of the participants were scanned before and after while doing an easy and a harder word task. After the program, the hard-skill group's brains were less busy on the easy version, so the step up to the harder one was bigger, in frontal, side and upper-rear areas tied to attention and word meaning. The easy-activity group didn't change that way. Evidence: decent The scans track blood flow, so this shows how hard those areas worked, not what changed inside them. Evidence: decent
Memory goes up. In the whole study, memory scores rose more in the hard-skill groups than in the social or at-home groups. Evidence: decent The brain change went with time put in and with the thinking gains, but that is a correlation in a small group. Evidence: worth trying Whether this counts as neuroplasticity in the strict sense, new connections rather than a change in how hard areas work, wasn't measured. Evidence: worth trying
The proof
- 221 adults aged 60 to 90 finished a 14-week program. The hard-skill groups spent on average 16.5 hours a week learning photography, quilting, or both. Their episodic memory, memory for events and details, improved more than in the social and at-home groups. Evidence: decent
- The photography group, 29 people, showed the clearest memory gain against the at-home group. Evidence: decent The quilting group's gain over it pointed the same way but wasn't significant. Evidence: decent
- The group that split its time between the two skills gained, but less than photography alone did against the same comparison. It's one study and not a direct test of one skill against several. Evidence: worth trying
- 39 of them were scanned before and after; the hard-skill group's brain activity adjusted better to how difficult the task was. Evidence: decent
- 26 were scanned again a year later, and some of that change was still there. Evidence: worth trying
How to do it
- Pick one skill that's new to you and will stay hard for a while. Photography with its software gained most; quilting didn't show a clear gain. Evidence: decent
- Several hours a week, for months. The study used about fifteen hours a week for fourteen weeks. Evidence: decent
- Get a teacher and set work. The groups had five hours of teaching and ten hours of homework a week. Evidence: decent Whether you need both wasn't tested. Evidence: worth trying
- Judge after three months, not three weeks. Evidence: worth trying
Watch out
It's one study, in older adults who worked ten hours a week or less, and about three quarters of them were women. Evidence: decent A language counts as a hard skill, but the trials of learning one after 65 found little: 11 weeks of Italian lessons did no more for memory and reasoning than relaxation classes, and 16 weeks of a language app matched a brain-training app on two tests. Evidence: decent You'll read that bilinguals get dementia four years later; that comes from clinic studies of lifelong bilinguals looking back, and studies that followed people forward found no protection. Evidence: decent Fifteen hours a week is what was tested. Five is a guess at the least that might count; nobody has checked. Evidence: worth trying Only the brain scans had a follow-up, in 26 people, so whether the memory gain lasts is unknown. Evidence: decent Socialising on its own didn't lift memory here. That says nothing against it for anything else. Evidence: worth trying