How to do it
- The one you'd miss least. The trial tested one platform, not all of them at once.
- Deactivate, don't delete. You can come back; in the trial most did, and reported using it less.
- Four weeks. That's the length tested.
- Decide where the hour goes. It freed about an hour a day, and it went somewhere whether people planned it or not.
What the month changes
- The feedtakes an hour a day
Deactivating freed about an hour a day on average. People didn't move it to other apps; they spent less time online overall.
- Your eveningsmove offline
The hour went to TV alone, other things done alone, and time with friends and family in person.
- Moodlifts a little
Happiness, life satisfaction, low mood and anxiety all moved the right way. Short daily check-ins by text showed no clear change.
- Youuse it less after
Weeks later they reported about eleven minutes a day less on the app. The authors think habit, or finding life without it better than expected; that part is their reading, not a measurement.
Why it works
A large trial of this paid 580 US adults to deactivate Facebook for four weeks and compared them with 1,081 who kept it. They spent less time online, more time offline, including with friends and family, reported feeling a little better, and when the month was up they said they used it less than the others did, on average. Evidence: decent
The pattern is the useful bit: a month is long enough to find out what the habit was standing in for. Evidence: worth trying
The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 3 min read.
What happens in your brain
This one is about time and habit, not a brain scan. Nobody measured the brain here.
The feed takes an hour. Deactivating freed about 60 minutes a day for the average person. They didn't shift it to other social media or other sites; they spent less time online overall. Evidence: decent
The hour moves offline. It went to watching TV alone, other things done alone, and time with friends and family in person. Evidence: decent
Mood lifts a little. On surveys, happiness, life satisfaction, low mood and anxiety all improved. The overall index rose by 0.09 standard deviations, about a quarter to 40 per cent of what the authors cite for self-help and therapy-type programmes. Short daily text-message check-ins pointed the same way but weren't significant. Evidence: decent
You use it less after. Several weeks after the month ended, the deactivation group reported using the Facebook app about 11 minutes a day less than the others, 22 per cent less. Evidence: decent Among iPhone users who read the figure off their phone's own screen-time count, the drop was less than half that and not statistically clear. Evidence: decent The authors suggest it's habit-forming, or that people learned they liked life without it more than they'd expected. That's their reading of the result, not something the trial could separate. Evidence: worth trying
The proof
- 2,743 Facebook users were recruited through ads and asked what they'd need to be paid to deactivate for four weeks. The 1,661 who'd do it for under $102 were randomly split: 580 were paid to deactivate, 1,081 weren't. The deactivation group was found deactivated on 90 per cent of checks. Evidence: decent
- Deactivating freed about 60 minutes a day, which went to offline activities, alone and with others. Evidence: decent
- The overall well-being index rose by 0.09 standard deviations: small but significant. Evidence: decent
- Weeks later, their reported Facebook app use was about 11 minutes a day (22 per cent) lower, and 5 per cent were still deactivated nine weeks after the experiment ended, against 2.5 per cent of the others. About 80 per cent of the deactivation group agreed the break was good for them. Evidence: decent
- It had a cost: the deactivation group knew less about recent news. Their views on political issues also became less polarised. Evidence: decent
How to do it
- Pick the platform you'd miss least. The trial tested one platform; quitting everything at once wasn't tested.
- Deactivate, don't delete. You can come back. In the trial, people came back and reported using it less. Evidence: decent
- Four weeks, the length tested. Evidence: decent
- Notice what fills the hour. In the trial it went partly to people and partly to TV alone. Evidence: decent Deciding in advance where it goes is my suggestion, not something tested. Evidence: worth trying
Watch out
One platform, one country, one month, in the run-up to a US election. Evidence: decent Whether it transfers to whatever you scroll is untested. Evidence: worth trying Everyone in the trial was willing to quit for under $102 and was paid to do it, so people who'd miss it more weren't tested. Evidence: decent The mood lift was small, and you'll likely know less about the news for a month. Evidence: decent