steady

Body · Moving

Rehearse the lift in your head

15 minEvidence: decent

Do this

Injured, travelling, or stuck at a desk: fifteen minutes imagining the exercise, as vividly as you can, muscles included. Most days.

How to do it

  1. Imagine it from the inside. Feel the muscle work, not a picture of yourself doing it.
  2. Maximal effort, in your head. The study had people imagine their hardest contraction.
  3. Fifteen minutes, most days. The main study used 15 minutes, five days a week, for 12 weeks.
  4. Use it when you can't train, not instead of training. Real training came out ahead.

In your brain

  1. Motor areasrehearse the move

    Across 75 scan papers, imagining a movement made planning and movement areas more active that also work when you really move. The main movement strip itself didn't show up consistently.

  2. Brain signalgets stronger

    In the twelve-week study, the strength gains came with a bigger signal recorded from the scalp, one tied to driving a muscle. The authors put the gain down to that.

  3. Muscledriven harder, not built

    Nothing was lifted, so the authors put the gain down to the brain driving the muscle harder, not to new muscle. The study didn't show muscle growth either way.

  4. Youlose less, gain some

    In a four-week wrist cast, people who imagined hard contractions lost about half as much strength. Real training still beat imagining.

Why it works

In a small study, people who only imagined doing maximal contractions, fifteen minutes a day, five days a week for twelve weeks, got stronger: 35% in a little-finger muscle, 13.5% in the elbow. The authors put the gain down to the brain learning to drive the muscle harder, not muscle growing. A group that trained the finger for real gained more, 53%. Evidence: decent

So this isn't a gym replacement, whatever the podcast said. It's a way to keep the nervous system's side of strength while you can't train. Six to eight people per group, one lab. Evidence: worth trying

The long readEvery step of the chain, each study with its numbers, and what's still unproven. 2 min read.

What happens in your brain

The movement areas rehearse. A review of 75 brain-scan papers found that imagining a movement makes a large network in the front and top of the brain more active, along with deeper areas and the cerebellum. Several of those areas also work when you really move. The main movement strip, which sends the final command to the muscle, wasn't consistently active. Evidence: decent

The brain's signal grows. In the twelve-week study, the strength gains came with a larger brain signal recorded from the scalp, one known to track how hard you drive a muscle. Evidence: decent The control group, who did nothing, didn't change. Evidence: decent

The muscle is driven harder. No weight was lifted, so the authors put the gain down to the brain sending a stronger command. Evidence: decent The study didn't show muscle growth either way, so "not muscle growth" is their reading, and a reasonable one. Evidence: worth trying

You lose less. People had a wrist and hand in a rigid cast for four weeks. Without imagery, wrist strength fell by 45%. With imagery of strong contractions five days a week, it fell by 24%. The imagery group also kept more of their ability to switch the muscle fully on. Evidence: decent

The proof

  • 30 young, healthy volunteers. Two groups of eight imagined maximal contractions, one of the little finger, one of the elbow, 15 minutes a day, five days a week, for 12 weeks. Finger strength rose 35%, elbow 13.5%. Six people who trained the finger for real gained 53%. Eight who did nothing didn't change. Evidence: decent
  • A 2018 review of 13 studies with 370 healthy adults: imagery training moderately improved maximal strength against doing nothing. Against real training, real training came out ahead. Bigger gains went with sessions of about 15 minutes. Evidence: decent
  • The wrist-cast study: imagery cut the strength loss roughly in half over four weeks. Evidence: decent

How to do it

  • Imagine it from the inside: the effort, the muscle working, not a picture of yourself. The main study had people imagine maximal contractions. Evidence: worth trying
  • Fifteen minutes, most days, while you can't train. Evidence: decent
  • When you can train again, train. Across studies, real training came out ahead of imagery. Evidence: decent

Watch out

Small groups, young healthy volunteers, one muscle at a time, one lab for the main study. Evidence: decent It keeps some strength; nobody has shown it builds muscle. Evidence: decent If you're injured, it sits alongside what your physio tells you, not in place of it.

Arrows to move, Enter to open, Esc to close.